The Foundation for the Study of Applied Economics (Fedea) has released a report this Wednesday in which it expresses its opposition to the draft Royal Decree that the Government is processing to establish the conditions for energy and environmental sustainability, as well as digital resilience and sovereignty, that data centers must comply with.
According to the entity, the regulatory proposal introduces "disproportionate" demands, complicates the economic viability of investments, and establishes a "discriminatory" bias regarding other productive activities.
The document, drafted by economist Diego Rodríguez, is framed within the public hearing procedure of the future regulation, which will affect all data centers of more than 1 megawatt (MW) of power that connect to the grid after its entry into force, regardless of whether they already have access and connection permits or not.
The analysis concludes that the decree could jeopardize a significant number of projects in Spain, nullifying the competitive advantage that today the high availability and lower relative cost of renewable generation in the country provides.
Hourly demands and cost increases
The study examines in special detail the obligations related to renewable electricity supply, particularly the imposition that, in each hour of the year, at least 80% of the consumption of data centers be backed by clean energy from self-consumption or long-term contracts (PPAs of at least 10 years) with generation plants.
Fedea emphasizes the "disproportionate" nature of this requirement by recalling that throughout the year 2025, the Spanish electrical system only exceeded 80% renewable production in 36 of the 8,725 hours of the year (0.4% of the total).
To be able to meet that hourly condition, the report argues that promoters would be forced to contract renewable capacity far exceeding what is necessary and to intensively deploy battery storage systems to smooth out generation profiles. According to the simulations included in the work, the levelized costs of this additional infrastructure could exceed 100 euros per megawatt hour (euro/MWh), which would make Spain lose its attractiveness in prices.
The text also questions the additionality criterion, which requires that PPAs be signed only with renewable installations put into service in the 18 months prior to the operation of the data center.
Fedea considers it inconsistent to prevent contracts with plants that have recently started operating, in a scenario where electricity demand is progressing below what was expected in the National Integrated Energy and Climate Plan (PNIEC) and technical and economic spills are increasing due to insufficient consumption.
In the same way, the 'think tank' draws attention to the fact that the Government's draft ignores nuclear energy and other low-emission technologies, unlike the European labeling scheme for data centers, which incorporates the low emissions factor indicator (LEEF) explicitly including nuclear generation.
Simultaneous objectives of energy and water efficiency
Although Fedea generally supports the introduction of criteria for efficient resource use, its overall evaluation of the regulation is negative. Firstly, it questions the obligation to simultaneously achieve the maximum rating (class A, on a scale from A to G) in both energy efficiency (PUE ratio below 1.15) and water use efficiency (WUE ratio below 0.1 liters per kilowatt hour).
In this regard, the report warns that this double requirement violates the recent European regulation on data center labeling, which recognizes a clear 'trade-off' between both parameters, given that improvements in water consumption often compromise advances in electricity consumption and vice versa.
As an alternative, the study proposes a more balanced solution, combining the highest requirement in one of the indicators (class A) with greater flexibility in the other (class A or B), which, in its opinion, would allow Spanish data centers to remain at the forefront of European technological advancement.
Furthermore, Fedea rejects the use of access and connection permits to the grid as leverage to condition the technical, environmental, and financial specifications of private business projects.
The analysis argues that the Royal Decree designs a particular and "discriminatory" regulatory framework for data centers, by imposing entry barriers that do not apply to other large industrial or financial consumers with comparable electricity consumption patterns.
In Fedea's opinion, this approach reinforces the drift of using access to the electrical grid as an additional instrument of industrial policy, in line with the prioritization of initiatives through the new Strategic Investment Committee or the introduction of 'ad hoc' criteria in capacity auctions.