Manuela Carmena criticizes the way the Justice system works: "Who are we writing the rulings for?"

The former deputy mayor of Madrid questioned the usefulness of part of the judicial work during the presentation of the book by Álvaro Lobato.

2 minutes

fotonoticia 20261027104543 1920
Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Published

Last updated

2 minutes

Manuela Carmena questioned the use of time and resources in the courts during the presentation of the book Justice, who is responsible? The world changes, justice does not, by the magistrate Álvaro Lobato Lavín. The former judge summarized her criticism with a sentence: "In justice, a lot is worked on in a very useless way."

The meeting, held on November 18 at Fide’s headquarters, also brought together the former Minister of Justice Rafael Catalá and the author of the work. The participants addressed the inertia of the judicial organization and the difficulties in assessing how it functions. The interventions pointed to different problems: from the day-to-day management of the courts to the criteria for appointing positions and the lack of incentives to improve the performance of judicial bodies.

The former mayor of Madrid cited as an example the record-ordering proceedings that are limited to acknowledging the filing of a submission. In her view, actions of that type consume time and resources without providing a substantial advance to the procedure. She also criticized the retention of forms of work that she described as "absurd mental utensils."

Carmena argued that the management of the courts must be approached as a function differentiated from the task of judging and proposed that that responsibility fall to specialists. At the end of her remarks, she left a question about the ultimate purpose of judicial decisions: "Who are we writing the rulings for?"

Catalá calls for objective criteria for appointments

Rafael Catalá focused his remarks on the system for appointing judicial positions. He considered that the lack of objective criteria makes it possible to negotiate quotas and defended more transparent procedures, based on the evaluation of capabilities and with participation from specialists in human resources.

The former minister also questioned the model of technological modernization. "We have incorporated a lot of technology, but to do the same thing," he said. Among the changes he proposed are reorganizing civil servant bodies, measuring workloads, and strengthening training in team leadership for those who aspire to government positions.

Lobato’s book puts the focus on judicial culture

Álvaro Lobato Lavín, a magistrate of the Commercial Courts in Barcelona, returned to the judicial career in 2022 after more than two decades of professional practice in the private sector. This dual experience serves as a starting point for analyzing the routines, incentives, and the institution’s capacity for transformation.

In Justice, who answers? The world changes, justice does not, the author argues that the main problem is not a lack of economic resources, but an organizational culture that barely measures results and offers little response to the lack of change. The work raises the need to evaluate how the courts function and assume responsibilities without turning that review into a threat to judicial independence.