The Advocate General of the CJEU casts doubt on Spain’s argument about State aid in order not to pay renewables awards

An opinion from the Advocate General of the CJEU calls into question the strategy of Spain and the EU to block the payment of arbitration awards to investors in renewables.

2 minutes

fotonoticia 20261120110310 1920
Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Published

2 minutes

The Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), Athanasios Rantos, has issued an opinion in which he challenges one of the legal pillars cited by the Spanish Government and the European Commission to halt the payment of arbitral awards to investors in renewables. Specifically, he calls into question the thesis that the financial compensations recognized for these investors constitute State aid incompatible with the rules of the EU internal market.

The statement, released this Thursday, is formally framed within a procedure that affects Romania, the well-known 'Micula case'. In it, it is argued that compensating for the economic harm suffered by an investor following a regulatory change does not, by itself, amount to granting State aid prohibited by the rules of the internal market. It also defends that this legal distinction is fully transferable to international arbitral tribunals, according to sources from the creditor funds that bought the rights to representation and collection from Spain for the cuts to the premiums for renewable energies.

This opinion, which is not binding, may become a serious setback for the legal strategy followed by the Spanish Executive, which explicitly relied on the jurisprudence of the 'Micula case' to prevent the payment of nearly three dozen awards arising from the retroactive cuts to renewable premiums. The amount still pending for these convictions already totals 2,367 million euros.

The European lawyer also rejects the appeal on points raised in support presented by Spain in this matter, by dismissing the thesis that investors would not have a legitimate interest to challenge before Community justice the decisions of the European Commission that block the execution of their awards.

According to the same sources, Rantos’s criterion also calls into question the March 2025 decision with which Brussels vetoed Spain’s payment of 101 million euros in the 'Antin case', by directly relying on the Romanian precedent that the Advocate General now proposes to annul through the revocation of its Article 1.

Similarly, the Advocate General’s reasoning casts doubt on the in-depth investigation opened by the Commission last August regarding the payment of €32.95 million made by Spain to the Japanese company JGC Holdings, which would suggest that the dispute goes beyond the EU sphere and could support the legality of that payment.

For the creditor funds, Rantos’ conclusions also undermine Spain’s position in the seizure and forced execution proceedings underway in non-EU jurisdictions such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia or Singapore, where the Government hid behind Brussels’ prohibition in an attempt to curb investors’ claims.

After this opinion, it will now be for the judges of the CJEU to deliver the final ruling and clarify whether one of Spain’s main legal arguments used to avoid compliance with arbitral awards in the renewables sector definitively collapses.