The Supreme Court has upheld the fine of 63,300 euros imposed on Rodman Polyships by the Consellería do Mar for “serious total breach” of the contract for the construction of two patrol boats intended for the Servizo de Gardacostas de Galicia.
In this way, the high court endorses the ruling of the Tribunal Superior de Xustiza de Galicia (TSXG), which had already dismissed the company’s appeal against the penalty set by the regional Administration in February 2023.
The origin of the dispute goes back to a tender promoted by the Xunta in 2022 for the manufacture of two surveillance vessels, with a base budget of 2.55 million euros. Astilleros Polináutica submitted to the competition, whose proposal was rated the highest, and Rodman Polyships, which came second.
Astilleros Polináutica did not manage to formalize the required definitive guarantee, as it did not obtain the bank guarantee in time, although it did deliver the rest of the documentation and requested an extension of the deadline. The regional Administration understood that it was withdrawing its offer and proceeded to demand the documentation necessary from Rodman.
However, the Rodman company provided no documents within the period granted and did not respond to the administrative request, which led the Xunta to consider its offer withdrawn as well and to impose a penalty of 3% of the base tender budget, excluding VAT, for a total of 63,300 euros.
In its decision, the Supreme Court confirms the sanction and finds that Astilleros Polináutica did try to comply with the request and only encountered obstacles in obtaining the bank guarantee, while Rodman did not submit any documentation nor explain the reasons why it ignored the administrative request.