The European Commission has opened an infringement procedure against Spain for establishing discriminatory tax obstacles affecting pension funds and life insurers from other countries, considering that Community rules on the free movement of capital are not being applied correctly.
The Brussels notice takes the form of a reasoned letter sent to the Spanish Government, in which it details the irregularities detected and grants a period of two months to correct the situation. If, within that time, the Community authorities do not consider Spain’s explanations satisfactory, the Commission may move forward to the next stage of the file by issuing a reasoned opinion, a step prior to deciding whether to refer the matter to the Court of Justice of the EU (TJUE).
Together with Spain, the Community Executive has launched infringement files of the same type against Belgium, Germany, Italy, Austria, Poland, Portugal and Romania, for also failing to comply with the rules on the freedom of movement of capital.
In its communication, the Commission emphasizes that the legislation of all the affected Member States “has discriminatory tax barriers to cross-border investment by foreign pension funds and life insurers”.
Brussels also stresses that this freedom is essential for the proper functioning of the European Union’s capital markets —a pillar in turn for the competitiveness of European companies operating in the single market— and for safeguarding the sustainability of the population’s pensions.
According to the Community services, the national rules of the countries identified favor local operators, since they exempt resident pension funds and life insurers from income tax generated by their investments, while subjecting to taxation equivalent pension funds and life insurance companies from other EU or European Economic Area States that obtain returns in their territory.
Likewise, the Commission points out that these national legislations prevent foreign pension funds and life insurers from deducting from their taxable base the technical reserves intended to cover future obligations to their clients, contrary to what happens with domestic pension funds and insurance entities, which can indeed deduct those reserves when calculating their income subject to taxes.