The insurance for a mortgage can respond to different situations. A policy required as a condition of the loan guarantee and a product taken out to obtain a discount must not be analyzed as if they were the same.
The penalty for Sabadell, already reported by Demócrata, has put that difference back in the spotlight today. The Colegio de Mediadores de Seguros de Madrid has also reported the fine of 16.5 million linked to the joint sale of loans and insurance.
For the customer, the check starts with the contract. The commercial name of the mortgage or a verbal explanation in the office do not replace the terms signed.
Required insurance and discounted insurance: the difference
Banco de España explains that regulations include certain types of insurance that may be required in order to grant a mortgage. In those cases, alternative policies with equivalent benefits must be accepted, without charging for analyzing them or worsening the conditions offered by that substitution.
Another issue is a combined offer in which the loan can be arranged separately and certain products allow a discount to be obtained. The supervisor recommends comparing the cost of the premiums with the savings from the discount.
The date of the contract and its wording matter. Before cancelling a policy it is necessary to check what specific effect it would have and whether an insurance coverage that is required is being replaced or a discount condition is being left unfulfilled.
Documents it is worth gathering
| Document | What to check |
|---|---|
| Loan deed | Terms, obligations and discounts. |
| FEIN, when applicable | Tailored offer and associated products. |
| Insurance policy | Coverages, exclusions, duration and method of payment. |
| Receipts | Actual cost of the premiums. |
| Offer without a discount | How much the loan would cost without the products. |
| Bank communications | Explained terms and response to the alternatives. |
How to calculate whether the discount is worthwhile
The comparison must be made in euros and for the same period. The loan savings must be weighed against the additional cost of the insurance and other products taken out to obtain it.
A hypothetical example: if a discount saves 240 euros per year and the bank’s insurance costs 350 euros more than an equivalent policy, the difference would be 110 euros per year against that option. The comparison is only valid if the coverages are truly comparable.
It also has to be checked whether the premium is paid every year or financed at once. The Bank of Spain highlights the importance of distinguishing the single premium from the periodic payment and of assessing whether the coverage fits the needs.
How to file a complaint if the terms have not been complied with
The first step is to submit a complaint to the Customer Service of the entity, keeping a copy and proof. The written complaint must identify the contract, describe what happened, and specify what is being requested.
For mortgage complaints from consumers, the Bank of Spain indicates a response deadline of one month. If there is no reply or it is unsatisfactory, the matter may be brought before the supervisor after proving that this prior step has been carried out.
When the dispute specifically affects the actions of the insurance company, the route may correspond to the Dirección General de Seguros y Fondos de Pensiones, after making a complaint to the entity. The competent body depends on the product and the reason for the complaint.
The administrative penalty does not replace the review of each contract nor does it, by itself, provide proof of an amount that must be returned to a specific client.