Can Sánchez approve the PSOE electoral program without going through the Federal Committee? This is what the Statutes say

The PSOE Statutes assign the Federal Committee with approval of the electoral program. What does Article 27 say and when can this competence be delegated

4 minutes

fotonoticia 20261114110609 1920
Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Published

Last updated

4 minutes

The PSOE electoral program for the general elections of November 29 has opened a debate about the party’s internal functioning and the powers of its governing bodies. Article 27 of the Federal Statutes establishes that it corresponds to the Federal Committee to draft and approve the state electoral program, but the document with which Pedro Sánchez is standing in the election has been published without any record of a vote by that body on its content.

The socialist program, which includes the model of autonomous financing agreed with ERC, something that was not submitted to the Federal Committee held last October 17 in Fuenlabrada. That meeting was devoted to ratifying the electoral candidacies. The question is whether the leadership could approve the document without convening a new meeting or whether it needed an express delegation of powers.

What the PSOE Statutes say about approval of the electoral program

The Statutes approved at the 41st Federal Congress of the PSOE attribute to the Federal Committee, the party’s highest governing body between congresses, responsibility for the program with which the party will stand in a general election.

Specifically, the article 27.1.d includes among its powers the following:

"Draft and approve the electoral program for the state scope, for the Cortes Generales and for the European Parliament".

The provision differentiates this responsibility from other functions assigned to the same body, such as establishing the fundamental lines of electoral policy, ratifying candidate lists, or determining the alliances policy.

Therefore, approval of the state electoral program statutorily corresponds to the Federal Committee, and not exclusively to the general secretary nor to the Federal Executive Commission.

Can the program be approved without convening the Federal Committee?

The Statutes themselves contemplate a relevant exception. Section two of Article 27 establishes that the Federal Committee may delegate its powers to other PSOE federal bodies.

This means that approval of a program without a specific vote by the Federal Committee could comply with internal rules if that body had validly delegated the corresponding competence.

The difference is essential: one thing is that the Federal Committee did not vote directly on the document and another is that approval took place without respecting the statutory procedures.

To determine whether there has been a breach, it would be necessary to check whether a delegation was approved, which body it was attributed to, and whether it included the drafting and approval of the electoral program for 29N.

What happened at the Federal Committee on 17 October

The last Federal Committee held before the publication of the program took place on 17 October in Fuenlabrada, where the socialists ratified their candidacies for the general elections.

According to the information published by El Español, the electoral program was not put to discussion or a vote during that meeting.

The document was later disseminated, on 15 November, when the electoral campaign had already begun.

No specific approval of the program by the Federal Committee, nor an express delegation for this document, is shown in the public information examined. This absence of information does not make it possible to rule out that there is an internal delegation agreement that has not been made public.

Why the Catalan funding model is at the center of the controversy

The controversy is of special relevance due to the inclusion in the socialist program of the new model of regional financing negotiated with ERC.

Measure number 229 incorporates the financing system proposed by the Government, which includes the principle of ordinality, a criterion through which it is intended to preserve the relative position of the communities based on their contribution and the resources received.

This model has caused disagreements within the PSOE itself. Regional leaders such as the president of Castilla-La Mancha, Emiliano García-Page, and that of Asturias, Adrián Barbón, have expressed their rejection of certain aspects of the proposal.

The electoral program therefore incorporates an initiative questioned by several socialist federations, despite the fact that its representatives were unable to debate or vote on it at the Federal Committee last October.

What happens if the Statutes of a political party are not complied with

Political parties have autonomy to organize their internal operations, but they must respect the legislation that regulates their activity and the rules included in their own statutes.

In the case of the PSOE, the Federal Commission for Ethics and Guarantees has assigned functions of interpreting the Statutes and resolving certain appeals related to the rights of members.

Membership can use the internal mechanisms provided when it considers that an action by the party bodies violates its statutory rights.

However, any eventual irregularity in the internal procedure for approving the electoral program does not automatically mean that the document is invalid before the Electoral Commission nor that the party loses its right to stand in the elections.

The scope of any breach would depend on the procedure used, on the competences effectively delegated, and on decisions that the internal bodies might adopt or, where appropriate, the courts.