Representatives of six scientific societies have transferred this Wednesday to the Ministry of Health their displeasure over the training program project for the specialty of Clinical Laboratory. They consider that the proposal encroaches on areas proper to other fields and have requested that it be reviewed and reformulated before it is approved definitively.
In particular, their opposition has been expressed by the Spanish Society of Immunology (SEI), the Spanish Society of Infectious Diseases and Clinical Microbiology (SEIMC), the Spanish Society of Hematology and Hemotherapy (SEHH), the Spanish Association of Human Genetics (AEGH), the Association for the Study of the Biology of Reproduction (ASEBIR), and the Iberian Society of Cytometry (SIC).
According to these organizations, the current version of the Clinical Laboratory program driven by Health incorporates competencies whose scope and level of autonomy could cause "overlaps" with functions that require specific own training. In addition, they warn that the text impacts both on specialties already established and on disciplines whose official recognition is still in process.
The entities have already submitted allegations to the project, whose period for hearing and public information ends next November 26, and they now seek a meeting with the Ministry of Health to directly set out their rejection and seek to reach an agreement.
In this context, the president of the Spanish Society of Immunology (SEI), Silvia Sánchez, does not rule out resorting to the judicial route if her demands are not met. "We will go as far as we have to in order to defend, above all, the quality of care for patients, at a time when medicine is moving toward greater super-specialization and not backwards," she has warned.
Interferences with Laboratory Genetics and Medical Genetics
The Spanish Association of Human Genetics has warned that the Health initiative could interfere with the development of the new specialties of Medical Genetics and Laboratory Genetics, whose degrees are currently in processing.
"The Clinical Laboratory program invades competencies proper to the new specialty of Laboratory Genetics," the president of the AEGH, Belén Pérez, has stated, who has recalled that in October the public consultation period for the royal decree that will regulate this specialty ended and that now it will have to continue its processing once the allegations submitted have been resolved.
Likewise, it has reiterated that the Clinical Laboratory project assigns genetics content with training periods of between two and seven months, a time that the AEGH considers insufficient to assume with the depth and autonomy necessary the responsibilities that are foreseen for the specialty.
In the field of Clinical Embryology, scientific societies warn that the inclusion of therapeutic procedures for assisted reproduction in the training program entails advancing decisions about a field whose recognition as its own specialty is still pending.
Risk of diagnostic delays and less well-supported decisions
The six societies recall that precision medicine requires professionals capable of selecting the appropriate test, interpreting its results according to each patient, and assuming responsibility for the decisions derived.
Along these lines, they insist that receiving training in a technique does not equate to being prepared to independently manage a complex care process. "If the program does not delimit who interprets, informs, and responds for each action, hospitals may adopt disparate criteria. For patients, this could translate into diagnostic delays, therapeutic decisions with less specialized support, and unequal access to expert teams depending on the center or the territory," they warn.
They also warn that this situation could lead to inappropriate use of diagnostic resources, increasing healthcare spending without necessarily providing an added clinical benefit.
For all these reasons, they call on the Ministry of Health to withdraw or modify the questioned competencies, clearly differentiate between shared training, supervised participation, and independent practice, and incorporate the submissions of the scientific societies and the national commissions of the affected specialties.
"The final text must ensure that any person receiving care in the National Health System can access the team with the training and experience that their case requires, regardless of the hospital or territory where they receive care," they conclude.