The former United Nations Special Rapporteur on human rights to safe drinking water and sanitation, Pedro Arrojo, who stepped down from the post last 31 October after exhausting the maximum permitted term, has warned that 50 percent of the aquifers in the Balearic Islands are in a bad or poor state, which constitutes a direct breach of the European Union’s Water Framework Directive.
During his appearance this Wednesday before the Committee on Climate Change on Agriculture, Livestock Farming and Fishing of the Parlament, he detailed that the archipelago wastes every day 67,000 cubic meters of water that has already been pumped, chlorinated and treated, a loss he has estimated at 24.5 million euros per year.
In this context, he considered clearly insufficient the target for leak reduction of 17 percent set in the regional water plan, and he compared it with the range of 3 to 5 percent applied in countries such as Holland.
Arrojo stressed that preserving the good status of the aquifers is “fundamental” and “essential,” especially in island territories such as the Balearic Islands, and he warned that overexploiting underground reserves in the name of economic growth implies “water for today and thirst for tomorrow”.
He also recalled that beneath the surface there is “more than 30 times as much fresh water” as in rivers and lakes, and he warned that, if this resource is not known better and is not managed correctly in terms of quantity and quality, it will be “condemning the future” of the next generations.
Likewise, he emphasized that it is “a disgrace” that in Spain around a million illegal wells function in water exploitation operations. The former Rapporteur rejected the use of the term “alegal,” denied that it is difficult to locate them, and attributed the absence of effective control to “a problem of political will.” “With very little money and a drone, it is detected quickly in summer where there is an illegal well,” he reiterated.
Arrojo also pointed out that the overexploitation of aquifers accelerates salinization due to marine intrusion, a process worsened by rising sea levels, and significantly increases the concentration of nitrates, which makes the process of making water potable more expensive.
For this reason, he has argued that preserving the 87 existing underground water masses in the Balearics (64 in Mallorca, six in Menorca and 16 in Eivissa), from which a total of 287 cubic hectometers are extracted, constitutes a “life insurance” without which it is not possible to speak seriously about adaptation to climate change.
The former rapporteur has also focused on the strategic role of wetlands as key tools in managing flood risk, as they expand when there is excess water and function as natural reserves during periods of drought. Although he has recognized that suitable laws and programs already exist, he has called for reflection on whether they are truly applied effectively or if they run into obstacles and “power asymmetries”.
More intense droughts and more extreme rainfall
In his analysis of the impact of climate change, Arrojo lamented that substantive changes are being made to rainfall patterns, along with a clear increase in temperatures, which results in more heatwaves and greater water demands, especially in irrigated areas.
In his view, this new climate reality implies more intense, prolonged and frequent droughts, while it also brings with it episodes of rainfall “also more habitual, more severe, more powerful and more fearsome”.
To deal with this scenario, he emphasized that there is “a legal obligation to manage risks” and has proposed strengthening both the environmental resilience of ecosystems and the social resilience of communities.
“When strategies are articulated not so much for mitigation, but for adaptation, then one has to adapt in order to minimize the impacts on society,” Arrojo reiterated, adding the need to protect, as a priority, the most impoverished communities.
Sponge cities and block tariffs
In response to questions from the PSIB and MÉS per Mallorca lawmakers, Pilar Carbonero and Marta Carrió, respectively, Arrojo has defended the design of sponge cities, with parks and floodable areas capable of absorbing rainwater.
According to his calculations, an urban permeabilization plan would allow infiltration of 400 liters per square meter, which in Mallorca, with 103 million square meters, would mean infiltrating 41 cubic hectometers, an amount higher than Palma’s urban demand, estimated at 30 cubic hectometers.
On this line, he has demanded "decisive" policies that include the defense of wetlands and the protection of coastal areas, and has questioned that current residents must assume the "rising costs" of resizing the networks due to the rapid urban and demographic expansion.
In addition, he has demanded the implementation of water tariffs with increasing consumption blocks and a specific social tariff for homes intended for vulnerable people.
"Do not give up public control of water management and sanitation," Arrojo has advised, who has emphasized that although he is not declared opposed to the market, he is also not in favor of "handing the market things that it does not know how to do".