The Sindicatura de Comptes de Baleares has warned that the repeated failure to comply with the spending rule by the Govern could entail "implications" in the long term if the dynamic followed in recent years is maintained.
The chief auditor of the oversight body, Joan Rosselló, issued this warning during his appearance this Tuesday before the Commission of Finance and Budgets, where he set out the main conclusions of the Sindicatura de Comptes report on the general account of the CAIB for 2024.
Rosselló has explained that this situation stems from the suspension of the fiscal rules that govern public administrations since the outbreak of the covid-19 pandemic. Nonetheless, he recalled that throughout all this time the provision has remained in force which establishes that public spending may only be increased in the same proportion as the economy.
As he detailed, between 2022 and 2024 the room for increasing CAIB spending was around 9%, but it ultimately rose to 26.7%, such that the regional executive would have ended up tripling the limit set by that reference.
Despite this mismatch, the auditor has specified that the overall opinion on the general account is "favorable", although they have detected "few" restrictions on access to information and certain exceptions that, he stressed, do not alter the final assessment.
Along these lines, he focused on an item of spending by IbSalut, close to 200 million euros, which is processed outside the ordinary administrative procedures and which is repeated systematically each year, despite the budget of the Conselleria de Salud being reinforced.
He noted that, in the health sector, in certain financial operations the file dossiers are formalized afterwards. This does not imply the absence of controls over those disbursements, but he insisted that "the risk does not cease to exist".
Likewise, he indicated that both the General Intervention of the State and that of the CAIB itself carry out "exhaustive" control over spending linked to contracts and grants. However, he emphasized that the Govern does not have a strategic anti-corruption prevention plan, something that has been implemented for the management of European funds as it is a requirement of the EU.
Another of the notices refers to the high average period of payment to suppliers. The regulations set a maximum of 30 days, but in 2024 it stood at 46 days and, in the specific case of IbSalut, it rose to 53 days.
Rosselló has indicated that these delays generate additional costs, since creditors go through the judicial route and claim late-payment interest. With regard to IbSalut, she has attributed this delay to the saturation of the administrative services tasked with arranging payments, a burden that increases as the budget grows.
In the healthcare sphere, she has quantified at around 17 million euros the outstanding debt of IbSalut for care for patients without coverage from Social Security—amounts that are diluted in the collection procedures. To address this problem, the Govern would have contracted a specialized company to manage these files.
Similarly, she has referred to the “lack of orthodoxy” of an accounting practice that has been maintained for some time, consisting of the Govern resorting to borrowing operations, instead of capital transfers, to finance bodies such as the Instituto Balear de la Vivivenda (Ibavi) or the Agencia Balear del Agua y la Calidad Ambiental (Abaqua).
She has specified that this formula is used for reasons of “budgetary stability” and does not involve any illegality, although she has emphasized that it is “strange” to choose this route, given that there may be entities that do not have sufficient resources to repay those funds.
“Greater risk of irregularities” in Montuïri’s accounts
In the same session, the syndic Maria Antònia García took the floor to present the report on Montuïri’s general account for 2024, an analysis carried out for the first time in this municipality.
The representative of the Sindicatura de Comptes has explained that they have abstained from issuing an opinion on the accounts of this local entity, as they could not ensure that the general account provides a “faithful” picture of its economic-financial situation.
Partly, this is because, although the documentation was submitted within the allotted time, they detected 11 limitations on access to information, 12 “very significant” incidents, and 23 breaches.
García has listed problems such as the absence of an internal control model in the Montuïri Town Hall, the incorrect calculation of the fiscal rules, or the lack of an inventory of property and rights of a budgetary nature.
Deficiencies also affect the payment of staff payrolls, where they have found errors in concepts such as productivity or the professional career. For this reason, they have demanded that the remuneration system be reviewed, the list of job positions be updated, and a timekeeping system be implemented.
The trustee has concluded that all of this stems from a "lack of accounting rigor" and from the fact that they cannot "trust" the available data, which entails "many risks" that a "distortion" will occur in municipal accounts and possible "irregularities".