Extension | Five EU countries agree with Rwanda on an external center to deport migrants starting in 2027

Five EU countries agree with Rwanda to establish a migrant deportation center starting in 2027, amid strong criticism from human rights organizations.

5 minutes

fotonoticia 20261116224336 1920
Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Published

5 minutes

Germany, Denmark, Greece, the Netherlands, and Austria have presented on Monday in Vienna an agreement with Rwanda to open in 2027 in that African country a center for the expulsion of migrants. To these facilities, citizens of third countries will be able to be sent without a residence permit in those European States, including those whose asylum application has been denied and who have rejected voluntary return to their place of origin, while the process for their final deportation is completed.

The Danish prime minister, Mette Frederiksen, has detailed in a joint appearance with the Austrian chancellor, Christian Stocker, that an understanding has been reached with Kigali to set in motion a "new mechanism for the return of migrants," which she has described as "decisive."

According to what the Social Democratic leader explained, accompanied by the Interior ministers of the four European partners and the head of Rwanda’s Foreign Affairs, Vincent Biruta, the scheme will allow the five countries to send to Rwanda "foreigners who lack legal residence" and, at the same time, "ensure that no more people arrive here than we ourselves want to accommodate."

In this way, people without legal status in those States, including those who have exhausted the asylum route without success, will be able to apply for a residence permit in Rwanda if they do not choose to return voluntarily to their countries of origin.

Frederiksen has argued that "now we are, truly, starting to regain control of Europe’s borders. We are initiating a fundamental transformation of the current asylum system, which is unsustainable and inhumane. And we are embarking on a fight against cynical people smugglers, who for far too many years have put human lives in danger and have profited from both them and our societies," and she has shown herself "extraordinarily satisfied" with the outcome of the negotiations.

In her view, it is "a day that will mark an era for Europe," because the measure is framed within a migration policy "much more in line with the will of European populations." Even so, she has emphasized that "no one flees for fun, and we must help people who are forced to flee. That is why we must provide more help in the regions near their countries of origin, and we will have better opportunities to do so when it becomes clear that it is not possible to reside in the EU without a legal basis for it."

The Austrian chancellor has described the pact as a "historic turning point in EU migration policy," while Biruta has justified cooperation by arguing that "uncontrolled migration does not benefit either the countries of origin or the destination countries."

The Rwandan official has emphasized that "Rwanda is a country with economic ambition." "We want to create an inclusive society. We want to offer asylum seekers whose applications have been rejected an opportunity in our country," he said, adding that his Government may grant residence permits to people transferred from the five European States.

So far, it has not been specified how many migrants will be sent to Rwanda. Biruta has stressed that the country will not receive "much money" for this cooperation and, consequently, it also does not expect that "thousands" of people will be diverted to its territory.

According to sources cited by the Rwandan portal IGIHE, European States will take on the financing necessary for the reception and care of the migrants. They will cover the costs of accommodation, training and support to start a new life, as well as transport to Rwanda. In addition, the resources will be directed toward promoting economic development in the areas where the reception facilities are built.

This arrangement constitutes the first agreement concluded by European Union countries with a third country to outsource part of migration management and returns to its territory. Until the recent reform of the EU asylum and return framework, approved by the Twenty-Seven to toughen removals, EU law did not include this type of device. Spain voted against specifically because of legal doubts regarding the figure of these deportation centers.

Germany keeps its distance from the British model

On the domestic front, German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt has maintained that return centers represent a "positive approach for people who have no right to remain and no prospects in Europe, whose countries of origin do not cooperate with repatriation efforts."

"We need this option to implement a migration policy that works," he argued, ensuring that the plans comply with German law, respect international human rights standards, and are developed in collaboration with international organizations.

He has also emphasized that the initiatives of the EU member states "are by no means comparable" to the failed UK asylum project with Rwanda.

Along the same lines, the chancellor Christian Stocker has defended that "our model is established in full harmony with EU law, International law and the international provisions on human rights" and has underscored cooperation with the European Commission, the International Organization for Migration and UNHCR.

Stocker added that "the EU Asylum Pact is an essential component for a tough, consistent, but also fair migration policy. The new EU Return Regulation now allows us to carry out returns also to third countries. Therefore, we make use of it."

Human rights organizations warn of risks

Various human rights advocacy groups have denounced that the project puts the guarantees of the people expelled to Rwanda at risk and that, in addition, it will channel resources toward a Government questioned for its track record.

Human Rights Watch researcher Clementine de Montjoye has recalled the "well-known track record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detentions, mistreatment in custody" and support for armed groups in the neighboring Democratic Republic of the Congo by the Rwandan Executive.

"Paying Kigali to host a deportation program will not only cause suffering and harm to the deported, but will also finance and give political weight to a Government responsible for serious human rights abuses in the country and abroad," she warned.

Amnesty International has also rejected the agreement, which in its view "repeats the mistakes of the past." "Sending people to a country where they have never been is irresponsible and involves a real risk that the agreement with Rwanda will turn into a cruel black hole for human rights," the organization’s expert Aimée Stuflesser said, who predicts that the plan will be like the previous ones: "illegal, unenforceable and expensive."

The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights, for its part, has stressed that any pact with a third country must "respect fundamental rights" and has warned of the risk of persecution for the people transferred. It has also recalled that unaccompanied minors cannot be the subject of deportation.