The metropolis of Shenzhen, in southern China, is at the center of the international spotlight by hosting a historic summit between the presidents of the United States, Donald Trump; China, Xi Jinping; and Russia, Vladimir Putin. It is an unprecedented meeting that brings together the top leaders of the three leading nuclear powers, with the aim of addressing the end of the war in Ukraine and the situation in Iran, evoking encounters that shaped the course of global geopolitics in the 20th century.
In parallel with references to the Yalta conference of 1945, which defined the international chessboard in the final stretch of World War II, the meeting will have as its central focus the control of nuclear weapons, one of the priority issues for Washington. The United States has managed to bring China to the table, an emerging power whose real capacity for nuclear armament remains in doubt, especially after the United States and Russia allowed the New START treaty to expire.
Chinese diplomacy, which acts as the organizer of the meeting and takes the opportunity to strengthen its global projection by bringing together the three heads of state, has stated that the three heads of state "will hold an in-depth exchange of views on important issues that affect world peace".
For his part, Putin highlighted the "great potential benefits" of the summit, arguing that the leaders of the major powers can "sit at the same table and exchange views, resolve any disagreement between states in politics, economy, and security by seeking compromises and balancing interests".
The U.S. president, meanwhile, expressed satisfaction at having managed to involve China in a meeting on arms control, something he had been calling for for years, and also hopes to move Russia toward concrete steps to end the war in Ukraine. "I think we are very close to achieving it. We are going to have a good meeting on that matter," he said before beginning his trip to Asia, which began in the Philippines to attend the summit of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN).
Yalta Summit?
José María Peredo, professor of Communication and International Politics at the European University, considers the analogies with the Yalta summit to be “exaggerated,” which was decisive for Europe’s future after the Second World War. Nonetheless, he underscores the relevance of the fact that the three great nuclear powers are seated at the same table and argues that the best outcome would be to open a new stage of cooperation in the field of nuclear armament.
A denuclearization pact “would generate an environment of greater understanding between powers that rival and in some cases confront one another,” the expert states, who notes that the Shenzhen meeting could inaugurate a phase of “competition and collaboration between powers” and not so much of “rivalry and confrontation.”
The premise, shared by the three leaders, is that greater coordination in certain areas prevents geopolitical and commercial clashes, reducing the risk that the tension “leads to a conflict, a war, a destabilization, or a hybrid war.”
In Peredo’s view, the main beneficiary of the meeting is Putin, who sits alongside leaders of political and economic giants. “This isn’t his place,” the professor says, interpreting that Russia is joining the summit thanks to its status as a nuclear power and to the open conflict in Ukraine.
Meanwhile, China projects itself as a pacifying force capable of bringing together the world’s top leaders and fostering consensus. The analyst from the European University adds that Xi also aspires to promote negotiation in the technological arena and in Artificial Intelligence that deepens cooperation and reduces the possibilities of a trade war.
Trump arrives in Shenzhen after the setback suffered in the midterm elections in the United States and seeks both to advance commitments on nuclear arms control and to ensure a framework of competition with the other powers that allows the U.S. economy to grow, following tensions stemming from the war with Iran. “What’s left for President Trump is to close the open conflicts,” Peredo summarizes.
Start thinking about the end of the conflict in Ukraine
In any case, the agenda is clearly conditioned by the war in Ukraine, after Washington has managed to reactivate contacts with Kiev and Moscow, with European partners prepared to join upcoming rounds and with the will to push for a just peace in Ukraine that supports a renewed European security architecture. This last point is of special interest to Russia, which intends to secure its demands in relation to NATO.
The comparisons with the historical citations of Yalta or with the Helsinki agreements, three decades later, are explained by the possible impact of the summit on the European security system. However, Peredo lowers these expectations and reminds that in Shenzhen there will be no representation, either European or Ukrainian.
In this sense, it avoids defining the meeting as decisive for the future of Ukraine or of the continent and rather interprets it as a possible boost to the negotiating process in Ukraine. "Decisive for the European continent, it won’t be. The character of urgency or of consequences for the European Union is within the European Union," he concludes.