The ballot boxes are already visible on the horizon. In a week, Spaniards will vote in the general elections to shape new Cortes Generales. Much is talked about the Congress because from its votes will come the new president and, consequently, the new Executive; but today we focus on the Senate.
Francesc-Marc Álvaro, the head of the list for Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (ERC) to the Upper House for Barcelona, faces the 29N with the conviction that the campaign can still turn around and that the mobilization of the left will be decisive to halt the advance of the right and the far right, which are leading according to the polls.
In this interview with DEMÓCRATA, he defends the role of the Senate as a space for forging agreements among Catalan representatives around language, infrastructure, and self-government, argues that the social agenda matters and calls on the PSOE for effective commitments both on housing and in resolving the political conflict between Catalonia and the State.
QUESTION: How does Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (ERC) view the election campaign? With the polls on the table, are there chances for the left?
ANSWER: Polls indicate that the right and the far right have the wind at their back, but it is also true that it is a very open campaign, with many undecided voters and with a great possibility of mobilization that plays in favor of the lefts. Therefore, unlike other times, what happens during these days will be decisive.
P: You have been a Member of Parliament and now you are making the leap to the Senate. What drives this change? What do you think can be done in the Upper House, at the regional level, that cannot be provided from the Congress?
R: The Senate, which is a highly criticized institution, allows for two very relevant things at this moment in public life. On the one hand, it brings the political process closer to the territories in a clear way and, therefore, deals with very specific problems of cities and regions. On the other hand, I believe the Senate allows for thematic approaches, undoubtedly much broader, and with a different time frame than that of the Congress.
Both of these things interest me a great deal and are relevant. I’ll give you two examples: everything that has to do with the legua, culture, and defense—in this case—of Catalan; and everything that has to do with Europe, strategic sovereignty, industrialization, and the defense of the social pact at a time when certain speeches are trying to break it.
P: Do you think there is a bigger window for consensus on these issues, perhaps less media-driven or with less focus, in the Senate?
R: To the extent that the context allows me, I am going to look for a certain collaboration, which is what we call in Catalan an agreement, among Catalan senators on issues that seem to me to be matters of the country. And I give you three examples: language, infrastructures, and the defense of the institutional standing of the Generalitat. I would like to involve myself in seeking basic agreements among Catalan senators.
P: Regardless of the group? PSOE, PP, Junts…
R: I am referring to the maximum number of Catalan senators who do not want to self-exclude. There are some who, in general, already exclude themselves, like Vox and PP. But I would like that, in some basic elements—again, language, infrastructures, and the defense of the institutional standing of the Generalitat—we could have multiple senators from various groups operate.
P: The Senate is the chamber representing territorial representation, but in the last legislature, due to the PP’s absolute majority, it has been relegated to a secondary role. Do you think it should be reinvented? How can its territorial usefulness be increased and/or prevented from being used in a partisan way, on one side or the other?
R: We come from a legislature in which the PP has used the Chamber in a devious way in order to stop the momentum of the Congress. That has been a problem, but that distortion, if the Standing Orders are not changed, can be done.
In any case, it should not be lost sight of that excessively tactical use ends up eroding the credibility of institutions. If the left had the possibility of doing the same thing now, but the other way around, we should think about to what extent that would or would not reinforce democratic credibility. There are many aspects of the Senate that perhaps should be reconsidered, but at this moment of polarization I don’t think we can do it.
P: Which ones? Any specific aspect?
R: There is one element that I think would be interesting in general, for Congress and for the Senate: access to both chambers for the participation of civil society bodies in a much more effective way that went beyond what we now understand as being present in committees.
There are committees in which witnesses are called. Perhaps it should be studied how some general interest groups can participate more openly in that. I haven’t thought through the specifics, but I do think that contemporary democracy requires that openness of the chambers to social actors.
P: The election programs are already on the table, and ERC has again placed the focus on the right to self-determination, proposing that a referendum be negotiated with international accompaniment. This idea had been set aside a bit, at least that seemed, to focus on more material issues.
R: It’s that there is no dichotomy. ERC is a party that unites, like no other, the struggle for social justice and the struggle for the national rights of Catalonia. It’s not one thing or the other, it’s both, and that is what separates us from our competitors in the electoral supermarket. The fact that the Catalan procés ended does not imply that the reality of the political conflict has been extinguished.
The political conflict Catalonia-Spain remains. The independence movement remains. The aspiration for a change of status quo remains. And at the same time, the demand for material life. ERC is also a party that wants good housing policies, trains that work, effective regional funding, etc.
P: At the beginning of this interview, you said that it looked bad for the left. There are the polls. But if a left-wing majority were to be reissued, what commitments would you ask of the PSOE and under what guarantees? Because there are partners who regret that agreements are reached on elements that are then not implemented or are implemented in that way.
R: On the level of material issues we have already announced that the first thing we are going to push in the Cortes is the idea of a family, a house. That is, to effectively resolve the housing issue, which at this moment has become a real public scandal and must be addressed with urgency, but also with the will to go beyond the tactical.
On a more structural level, we are going to seriously explore the PSOE’s commitment to resolving the political conflict. Because once amnesty has been approved, what is now necessary is that, if the PSOE truly identifies with plural Spain, what it must do is make room for the resolution of that political conflict, one that is agreed upon and allows people to be consulted without them getting beaten up.
P: To conclude, I want to ask you what results on 29N would be considered a success for ERC and what forecast you make.
R: We notice that people come closer to us; we are in a good moment and there is a very high level of connection throughout Catalonia, both in urban areas and in the county regions. ERC is a very competitive offering, and many citizens have understood that we are the useful vote in a double sense: it serves to stop the far right and to defend the interests of Catalonia and its citizens.
Let’s say that many citizens have seen that we are the 2x1, that you can stop the ultras and defend Catalan reality in a single vote. Because, let’s put it clearly, the enemies of freedoms are also the enemies of freedoms in Catalonia. ERC is increasingly perceived by many voters as the best tool and as the most useful vote, given that the Catalan Socialists, when they get to Madrid, dissolve within the PSOE, and Junts ends up entering a logic, which is voting for many things alongside PP and Vox.
Therefore, ERC has a very wide lane to operate, and in these elections many voters have confirmed it and we are noticing it.