The European tobacco reform has encountered an obstacle within the European Commission itself. The Regulatory Scrutiny Board, a technical oversight body integrated into the Community institution but independent in its opinions, has issued a negative opinion on the impact assessment of the restrictions that Brussels is preparing for e-cigarettes, heated tobacco and the nicotine pouches. The decision requires correcting the analyses before continuing with the ordinary processing and could delay until 2027 a proposal that the Community Executive expected to present before the end of this year.
The competencies of the Regulatory Scrutiny Board
The Board is part of the administrative structure of the Directorate-General Secretariat of the European Commission, although it acts with autonomy from the departments that draft the legislative proposals. It is made up of nine members, including four experts selected outside the institution, and it has been tasked with reviewing the impact assessments of the new initiatives, as well as certain analyses regarding existing legislation.
Its task consists of checking whether the measures are sufficiently justified, whether the evidence used is solid, and whether their economic, social, and environmental consequences have been examined. It has no powers to approve or reject laws, but its opinions condition the progress of legislative files.
The setback affects one of the main projects of the European Health Commissioner, Olivér Várhelyi, who is in favor of tightening the regulation of alternative products to the conventional cigarette. As published by Eunews and Brussels Signal, the opinion, adopted on November 9, calls into question the solidity of the assessment prepared by the Directorate-General for Health and Food Safety (DG SANTE). Among the shortcomings identified would be the scientific justification for certain restrictions, their proportionality, the economic and social consequences, and the link with tobacco taxation.
The European Commission will have to review the document and resubmit it for examination by the Board. If it were to receive a second negative opinion on that same assessment, the proposal could only continue through an exceptional political procedure, which requires submitting the decision to the College of Commissioners. For now, Brussels has not confirmed a postponement of the reform, although the specialist press considers that the review could push its submission back to 2027.
The negative opinion does not mean that Brussels has given up on legislating, nor that its oversight body has ruled out the health risks of these products. What it calls into question is the quality of the analyses used to justify the measures and their possible consequences. The full text of the new opinion has not yet been published, so its specific objections are known through the information disseminated by the specialist press.
Featured story
Spain wants moderation in minimum tobacco taxes ahead of the directive Brussels is negotiating
5 minutes
Two negative opinions on different documents
This is not the first time that the Regulatory Scrutiny Board has questioned the preparatory work of the European Commission in matters of tobacco. In December 2025 it issued another negative opinion, published officially in April 2026, on the assessment of the directives currently in force. At the time, it warned of shortcomings in the interpretation of certain scientific evidence, in the analysis of the effects of legislation, and in the assessment of national policies that also influence consumption.
The difference between the two pronouncements is relevant. The first examined the results of existing rules; the second, the expected consequences of the future reform. It is therefore not a matter of two consecutive rejections of the same impact assessment, but of objections to different documents, even though they are related to the same EU policy.
In addition, the procedural consequences are different. A negative opinion on the assessment of a current rule does not necessarily prevent publication of the corresponding report. By contrast, when it affects the impact assessment of a new legislative initiative, as is the case now, the services of the European Commission must correct the document and resubmit it before continuing the ordinary procedure.
Várhelyi studies softening some restrictions and giving more room to Member States
As DEMÓCRATA has been able to learn through sources familiar with the European negotiations, the Health Commissioner, Olivér Várhelyi, is studying reducing the scope of some of the restrictions envisaged in the reform. Among the options examined is leaving to the discretion of the Member States measures such as plain packaging, the ban on nicotine pouches, and certain restrictions on the flavors of electronic cigarettes.
The possibility of introducing these changes forms part of the alternatives being considered to facilitate the review of the impact assessment. For now, the European Commission has not adopted any definitive decision on the content of the proposal.
The scientific controversy over products alternative to cigarettes
One of the main issues that accompanies the reform is how to regulate products that contain nicotine, but they work through different mechanisms than those of traditional cigarettes.
Publicly, Várhelyi has defended a restrictive position and has warned that alternative products can cause health harms comparable to those of conventional tobacco. His department considers it necessary to update the rules to protect especially minors and to respond to the increase in consumption of new forms of nicotine.
The scientific discussion, however, requires distinguishing between products and types of risk. Conventional cigarettes burn tobacco and generate smoke with numerous toxic and carcinogenic substances. Heated tobacco devices, electronic cigarettes, and nicotine pouches have different exposure profiles, although none is exempt from risks.
In the case of nicotine pouches without tobacco, the absence of combustion and inhalation of smoke implies a relevant difference with respect to the conventional cigarette. Toxicological analyses have identified a lower presence of certain harmful compounds, although long-term studies are still needed to establish how those exposure differences translate into health outcomes.
Another issue examined is the so-called “entry door effect,” regarding the possibility that consumption of alternative nicotine products could subsequently favor the use of conventional cigarettes, especially among young people.
In this regard, and according to the specialized press, the Board would have requested a more solid justification for certain conclusions included in the impact assessment.
Sweden, the European country with the fewest smokers and a growing consumption of nicotine pouches
Sweden has become a reference within the European debate on products alternative to conventional cigarettes. According to Eurostat, in 2023 it was the European Union country with the lowest proportion of smokers, 8%, compared with the 24% community average. Data from the Swedish Public Health Agency show that in 2024 barely 5.4% of the population aged between 16 and 84 smoked daily. The decline in smoking has coincided with the expansion of non-combustion nicotine products, especially tobacco-free pouches, whose consumption has increased among young people. Their marketing has spread in a country where there is a long tradition of using snus, an oral product that does contain tobacco.
The Swedish case offers a relevant reference for the European debate, although its results must be interpreted with caution. The decline in smoking began before the expansion of nicotine pouches and has coincided with prevention policies, taxes, and restrictions on consumption. For this reason, it is not possible to attribute exclusively to these products the reduction in the number of smokers. It does allow observing the evolution of consumption in a market where different alternatives to conventional cigarettes coexist, a circumstance of interest for evaluating future regulatory measures.
Featured story
The last cigarette of discord: Ireland wants to finalize the new tobacco taxation in November
7 minutes
Which directives does the European Commission want to reform
The initiative of the European Commission comprises two fundamental rules: Directive 2014/40/EU, which regulates the manufacture, presentation, and marketing of tobacco products and other related products, and Directive 2003/33/EC, concerning advertising and sponsorship. Brussels intends to adapt them to a market in which products have gained presence that barely existed when the current legislation was adopted.
Although e-cigarettes and heated tobacco are already subject to specific European provisions, tobacco-free nicotine pouches lack an equivalent harmonized regime within the current Directive on Tobacco Products. Member States have developed different national regulations, a situation that the European Commission intends to address through the reform.
Among the options examined are the expansion of the scope of application of the directives, new labeling requirements, restrictions on certain aromas, and stricter regulation of digital advertising. There is still no definitive legislative proposal that would make it possible to know which measures will be incorporated, their possible exceptions, or the adaptation timelines.
The proportionality of the restrictions and their economic consequences
The objections attributed to the Board also affect the proportionality of the restrictions and their legal basis. The European Union may harmonize certain internal market rules in order to guarantee a high level of health protection, but it must justify the need to intervene and respect the competences that fall to the Member States.
The assessment must also quantify the consequences of the different regulatory options for manufacturers, distributors, specialty stores, and employment, along with the expected health benefits.
The goal is for the European Commission to have sufficient information to compare alternatives and justify the proportionality of the measures, without the economic analysis replacing the priority of protecting public health.
The review must also take into account that Member States apply different taxes, consumption restrictions, and health policies, which makes it difficult to attribute all the observed changes to a single Community rule.
The tax reform moves forward despite obstacles to health regulation
The health review follows a different procedure from that of the reform of excise duties on tobacco. In July 2025, the European Commission presented a proposal to amend the Directive 2011/64/EU, with the aim of updating the tax minimums and incorporating new product categories into the European tax framework.
This file has continued to move forward while health regulation has encountered difficulties. At the meeting of the Council for Economic and Financial Affairs on 9 November, 26 Member States endorsed the Presidency of Ireland’s compromise text, while Malta maintained its opposition, as reported by Eunews.
If Ireland fails to reach an agreement, Lithuania will inherit the negotiations
As our correspondent reported from DEMÓCRATA in Brussels, Álvaro Villarroel, the reform of excise taxes on tobacco requires unanimity among the Twenty-Seven, so the opposition of a single member state is enough to prevent its approval. The previous Cypriot Presidency tried to bring positions closer through successive compromise texts, with concessions on minimum rates and the tax updates linked to inflation.
Ireland has resumed negotiations with the aim of closing an agreement before December 31, 2026. If it does not achieve it, Lithuania will take over the file on January 1, 2027, when its semester at the helm of the Council of the European Union begins.