The Electoral Board rejects Vox's complaint against 'La Revuelta' and endorses the cuts in the interview with Abascal

The organization considers that editing an interview to fit the program’s length does not involve discriminatory treatment and reminds that RTVE is not required to provide the parties with the complete recordings

4 minutes

abascal la revuelta poder digital
Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Published

Last updated

4 minutes

The Central Electoral Board (JEC) has rejected this Thursday the complaint filed by Vox against 'La Revuelta' for not broadcasting the interview in full that David Broncano conducted with Santiago Abascal last November 9. The body considers that the removal of 40 minutes of recording does not constitute a discriminatory practice against the candidate and defends the editorial autonomy of the media outlets, also during election processes.

In its ruling, known this Thursday, November 19, the Electoral Board explains that the RTVE program has an entertainment format in which the conversations take place without a closed script. This circumstance makes it common for interviews to extend beyond the time available on television and to have to be edited before broadcast.

Against Vox’s accusations, which had denounced an arbitrary selection of its candidate’s responses, the JEC concludes that no evidence has been provided of conduct intended to electorally harm Abascal. It also rules out that RTVE has an obligation to publish or provide the party with the segments that were left out of the program.

The Electoral Board defends the editorial autonomy of 'La Revuelta'

Vox had gone before the Electoral Board after considering that the editing of the interview violated the principles of political pluralism, equality, proportionality, and information neutrality required of public media during election periods.

According to the document filed by the party, the program’s management had removed approximately 40 minutes of responses on policy issues, including healthcare, energy, and public services. The party complained that the cuts had been decided unilaterally and without allowing it to intervene in the selection of the content.

The JEC rejects that line of reasoning and recalls that the principles governing election information must be reconciled with the editorial freedom of the media. Requiring the full broadcast of all the responses would, according to its ruling, turn interviews into spaces where professionals would lack the capacity to decide the content.

The body emphasizes that the format of 'La Revuelta' is based on spontaneity and that editing the conversations is a common practice, applied also to other guests and electoral candidates.

Vox does not provide evidence of discriminatory treatment

Another of the central arguments of the ruling is the absence of evidence that would make it possible to confirm that the edition responded to an intention to harm Vox.

The group had questioned both the cuts and David Broncano’s performance during the interview, especially due to the presenter’s interruptions while Abascal developed his answers.

However, the Electoral Board considers that the interviewer has a broad margin to conduct conversations, decide on the topics, and set the pace of the program, without all of his interventions having to be adjusted to the candidate’s preferences.

The ruling expressly distinguishes between an entertainment interview and the news segments intended to disseminate electoral proposals, such as those included in RTVE’s coverage plan for the general elections of November 29.

That difference proves decisive in resolving the complaint. The Electoral Board understands that 'La Revuelta' has no duty to provide parties with a space to reproduce their electoral program in full or to hand over all the recorded material.

Broncano had already defended the cuts and rejected publishing the 40 minutes

The complaint came after Vox accused RTVE and the production company El Terrat of failing to comply with the conditions agreed for the November 9 interview. The party demanded that the remaining 40 minutes be broadcast or that a complete copy be provided so that it could use Abascal’s statements on its own channels.

During the program broadcast on November 16, Broncano responded publicly to these demands and explained that the editing of the interviews forms part of the normal operation of the segment.

As an example, he recalled that approximately 50 minutes had also been removed from the interview conducted with Pedro Sánchez. The presenter argued that the cuts did not respond to political criteria and ruled out publishing the additional material claimed by Vox.

The controversy had already had other consequences. On November 11 of last year, Vox canceled the interview Abascal had scheduled with Jordi Wild on 'The Wild Project', after demanding new conditions regarding the control and subsequent use of the recordings.

The content creator explained that he had committed to publishing the full conversation and without modifications, but he rejected that the candidate’s team had control of the recording. Jordi Wild publicly expressed his disappointment over the cancellation.

'La Revuelta' was not obliged to interview Abascal

The controversy was also preceded by doubts about whether the Electoral Board had forced the Broncano program to invite the Vox candidate.

However, both RTVE and the Electoral Board itself clarified that there was no resolution that required that interview. The public corporation explained that it had decided to invite the main candidates for the Presidency of the Government by following the criteria applied to other entertainment programs.

RTVE’s official electoral coverage plan includes interviews and debates with specific times and conditions, but it does not include 'La Revuelta' among the news spaces subject to that allocation.