The Provincial Court of Lugo has imposed a sentence of nine years and seven months in prison on a man for assaulting and illegally keeping his ex-partner held at her home, located in Xove, in October 2021. The woman, who seriously feared for her physical integrity, was forced to flee by throwing herself out of a second-floor window into the building’s interior courtyard, which caused her serious injuries.
The court considers him responsible for three offenses: unlawful entry into a home, illegal detention, and aggravated injuries. Along with the prison sentence, he is ordered to pay the victim compensation of 21,500 euros for the physical and psychological harm caused. However, the Provincial Court rules out the offense of attempted homicide, understanding that it has not been proven that he acted with the intention of ending his ex-partner’s life.
The decision specifies that the injuries suffered by the woman when she fell out of the window are also attributable to the convicted man, since it was the situation of violence and risk generated by him that led her to make that extreme decision in order to escape. The judgment emphasizes that the victim remained “at all times under the control and supervision of the defendant”.
The events occurred on October 22, 2021. According to the woman’s testimony at the trial, the relationship had ended about two weeks earlier and, since then, she had blocked her ex-partner on the phone. That day, when she was returning home, he entered the building lobby insisting that they should talk, but she asked him to leave. According to her statement, the accused disregarded her request and entered the apartment without her consent.
Once inside, he would have held her and taken her to the living room, where an assault began during which, always according to her account, he pushed her against the wall, threw her to the ground, and tried to strangle her. The woman stated that she tried to ask for help while shouting and that she ended up hitting him with the keys she was holding in her hand, but he snatched them away from her.
The confrontation continued in the kitchen, where there was a struggle involving a knife. The victim stated that she did not dare to use it against the man and that she ended up handing it to him, despite the fact that he repeatedly told her to cut him because he did not care.
According to her account, the accused continued to hit her and even told her that she “had nothing to lose.” Fearing that the assault would continue, she took advantage of the fact that the man was heading back to the kitchen to run into an adjacent room and throw herself out the second-floor window into the interior courtyard of the building. She explained that the front door was closed and she did not see any other way out.
“No one listened to me. No one came to my aid. No one came to give me a hand,” she stated at the hearing to justify why she decided to throw herself out the window. She also indicated that it was not the first time she had suffered episodes of violence at the hands of her former partner, although on a previous occasion she had forgiven him.
The accused, meanwhile, denied having gained entry by force. He answered only the questions put by his defense and, for the most part, with monosyllables. He maintained that he was outside the building, that the door was open, and that she allowed him to enter. According to his version, they went up the stairs together and he did not use force to enter the dwelling. He also denied having keys to the home.
With regard to the struggle, he said it was the woman who hit him with the knife in his right hand and that she went to the bathroom on her own feet, adding that he did not see the moment when his former partner threw herself out the window.
The forensic doctors who testified at the trial examined the victim’s injuries and explained that it was not possible to determine which damage occurred during the assault and which resulted from the fall, although all the wounds were consistent with both episodes.
The woman suffered a fracture of the bones of the nose, a deep incised-contused wound in the left eyelid, a bruise on the right elbow, a fracture of the distal extremity of the right radius, a wound at the joint of the left index finger, and a bruise on the right thigh.
In addition, she had to undergo two surgical interventions and receive psychiatric treatment for an adjustment disorder. Among the aftereffects she suffers are scars on the eyelid, the hand, and the elbow, as well as a moderate impairment due to post-traumatic stress.
During the hearing, it was also analyzed whether there had been undue delays, with the finding of a delay of around a year in the processing of the judicial procedure.
The sentence handed down by the Provincial Court of Lugo is not final and may be appealed to the Superior Court of Xustiza de Galicia (TSXG).