The National Commission for Markets and Competition (CNMC) has urged the Official Credit Institute (ICO) to carry out a “strengthening of the reasoning” of the decisions with which it intervenes in the market, in order to avoid negative impacts on competition between operators.
The supervising body has spoken this Thursday about the draft royal decree that revises the ICO’s bylaws with the aim of adapting them to the execution of the program 'España Crece'.
According to the CNMC’s view, when the ICO acts to correct a market failure it must assess that there may be other ways to resolve it, such as adopting specific regulatory measures or instruments of a fiscal nature.
In this regard, the regulator’s report highlights that “it is recommended to strengthen the reasoning of the decision to intervene in the market, so as to ensure that the market failures or other objectives pursued have been correctly identified, that there are no alternatives that could be more efficient, and that this is in line with the principles of good regulation and administration, guaranteeing that it is necessary, efficient and proportionate”.
The report also proposes to further precisely define the functional areas of action of the ICO, so that the generic reference to strategic sectors does not serve as a basis to intervene without previously justifying the need and proportionality of each specific transaction.
Likewise, the CNMC proposes strengthening incentives for efficiency in the consideration that the ICO receives for the services it provides, taking as a reference the usual market costs of other operators that carry out similar functions, and verifying in any case the consistency of these actions with the rules on State aid.
The regulator adds that the ICO should award mandates to participating managing companies following objective and public criteria, aligned with public procurement legislation. It also considers it advisable to ensure transparent and non-discriminatory access to the intermediary activities, including for smaller-dimension entities, and to make public the essential conditions of the agreements that are signed.
The CNMC’s opinion incorporates a dissenting vote from Joan Capdevila, a member of the body proposed by ERC. In his view, the review of the ICO’s actions must be expanded with explicit recommendations about the territorial fit of the financing.
This adviser argues that collaboration with the relevant administrations and with their financial entities can provide key information about financing needs, existing instruments, and possible overlaps. This issue takes on special importance since the new statutes consolidate the promotional function of the ICO in areas such as housing, rehabilitation, industry, or social facilities, where the autonomous communities have extensive powers.