The legal representation of Andic has positively assessed that the ruling handed down by the Audiencia de Barcelona allows the investigation to be redirected toward the option of “considering the child of Mango’s founder to be innocent.” It has also highlighted the relevance of the dissenting opinion, which places emphasis on the “dubious evidentiary intensity that would have to lead to mitigating the strictness of the precautionary measures.”
“The aforementioned dissenting opinion sets out and breaks down that, in the judge’s view, the body of evidence she sees lacks support from sources of concrete investigative material,” the defense said this Wednesday in a statement, highlighting that this analysis calls into question the solidity of the evidentiary basis used to justify the most severe measures.
From the reasoning developed by the Chamber, the lawyers have stressed that the accidental hypothesis “preserves elements of plausibility and cannot be ruled out, and notes that the victim’s physical limitations allow for an eventual loss of balance to be explained.” In their view, this assessment opens the door to valuing alternative scenarios to the incriminating account with more attention.
The defense maintains that the evidence can justify the continuation of the proceedings, but insists that those that serve as support for a measure of pretrial detention must have “a certain intensity, be weighty, reach the level of sufficient reasons for imprisonment,” requirements which, in its view, do not apply in this procedure.
In their statement, the attorneys consider that this decision “balances the debate, focuses on the need for a calm trial with equality of arms, and reminds that criminal reproach requires something more than conjectures, speculations, or evaluative biases,” thereby asserting a more rights-guaranteeing analysis of the evidence before imposing serious restrictions on freedom.