The Civil Guard concludes in a report that “it cannot be concluded” that the Moroccan authorities acted “with an obvious dereliction of duty” on the day prior to the mass entry of immigrants into Ceuta at the end of July, although they did note that dereliction on the day of the incursion itself, when they warned: “Now they are indeed letting them through.”
This analysis appears in a document sent to the judge of the National Court María Tardón, who is investigating the case regarding the mass entry, and to which Europe Press has had access.
The report transcribes a conversation between an agent of the Armed Institute and a member of the National Intelligence Center (CNI). Their first contact took place on 29 July, when the CNI representative stated that they had information “about an attempt to enter by swimming and jumping over the fence,” coinciding with the “day of the King’s Throne Festival,” as well as the existence of “several groups on Fb --Facebook-- and WhatsApp encouraging these entries.”
The following day, once the mass entry had already begun, the civil guard reported that “the situation in Ceuta remains out of control” and “with no possibility of improvement” due to the “saturation of the resources,” a situation which, as he indicated, “could only improve somewhat” “with a very important reinforcement of aquatic resources on the part of Morocco.”
In response to this description, the CNI agent asked whether “the Moroccans are collaborating.” The guard replied that his “collaboration with them is limited because there are no refusals,” and emphasized that he did not know whether that attitude was due to a deliberate decision or not, by pointing out that he did not know whether they were doing it “with intent or not.”
Hours later, already at midday, “thousands of people were gaining access massively through the El Tarajal breakwater,” at which moment the representative of the Civil Guard called the CNI again to warn that “now they are indeed letting them through.” The intelligence agent confirmed the scene: “We are seeing it live; they enter in a flood.”
“Collapse of the elements of containment” at the border
The report states that “although it is not clear why they might be letting them through, there is no apparent reason for the moment and there is a certain sense of overflow; everything is very preliminary and there are not enough data at the moment,” according to a phone conversation of the Armed Institute agent.
In that context, it is detailed that between 8.00 a.m. on the 29th and 8.00 a.m. on the 30th, 1,109 swimming entry attempts were recorded in Ceuta, of which Morocco intercepted 493, "so it cannot be concluded that the Moroccan authorities acted with an obvious failure to carry out their duties."
Despite this, the Guardia Civil maintains that on July 30 "the collapse of the border containment and response elements occurred" and that, given the magnitude of the entry, "there was no operational police solution that could have counteracted it."
"Due both to the extraordinary volume of people attempting to cross the border irregularly by swimming to access national territory, and to the serious risk to physical integrity that the way they tried to do so entailed, the available capacities were essentially devoted to developing actions aimed at preventing the loss of human lives at sea or in the vicinity of the border breakwater," the document states.
The report also points out that the origin of the mass entry "could have been generated in a confluence of a multitude of potentially disconcerting factors, in a sudden manner in very little time, with a window of opportunity parameter, highly boosted on social networks, that decisively influenced" those who decided to cross.
According to the Guardia Civil, these people made up "a highly vulnerable social group, psychosocially dissatisfied and emotionally exposed to change, exceeding the forecasts and resources available, on one side and the other of the border."