The Administrative Litigation Court number 7 of Barcelona has declared null and void the decision of the Department of Labour of the Generalitat to leave without effect "for all purposes" the teleworking of its deputy directors-general, as stated in the ruling consulted by Europa Press this Tuesday.
This ruling is known one day after the Administrative Litigation Court 14 of Barcelona validated that the Generalitat withdrew the authorizations for distance work from the deputy directors-general and from positions that are organically comparable, by understanding that teleworking does not constitute a subjective right for staff, but rather a reversible organizational form and "a discretionary power" of the Administration.
In this new ruling, the magistrate upholds the appeal filed by 21 holders of deputy directorates-general and assimilated positions against the Department of Economy and Finance, as a result of the instruction issued at the beginning of 2025 by the Secretariat of Administration and Public Service of the Generalitat.
The judge leaves without effect the challenged decision by considering that the instruction introduces an amendment that clearly alters "the content" of Decree 77/2020, which regulates the provision of services in a teleworking regime for staff serving the Administration of the Generalitat.
Exception not provided for in the decree
According to the reasoning of the ruling, the suppression of teleworking constitutes an exception not contemplated in the decree, and therefore it concludes that said instruction is null and void in full right for contravening what is established in an administrative provision of higher rank.
The ruling adds that, once the instruction has been declared null and void, the administrative decisions appealed against also become null and void, since they rely exclusively on that instruction.
Likewise, the court establishes that it is not appropriate to impose procedural costs on any of the parties, since no lack of 'iusta causa litigandi' is found given the existence of doubts of fact and law.