The virtual FP in the face of an increase in costs that the RD education project does not link to quantified educational improvements

The Ministry of Education estimates that reducing students per teacher would raise from 429 to 772 euros the cost of teaching staff per student and per school year. Education expects more personalized care, while objections from the sector ask to justify the limits and assess their effects on prices and supply

fotonoticia 20260928155101 1920

fotonoticia 20260928155101 1920

Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Ask FREN

Published

6 minutes

Most read

Elecciones 29N · Encuestas

La media de las encuestas

Media a 18 de noviembre de 2026 · 17 institutos

  • PP31,4 %
  • PSOE27,3 %
  • Vox18,9 %
  • Frente Amplio6,2 %
  • ERC2,4 %
01020304050ene 2024jul 2024ene 2025jul 2025ene 2026jul 2026

Media del último estudio de cada instituto en 30 días y su evolución semanal desde el 23J. Partidos con al menos un 2 %.

Todas las encuestas

Elecciones generales del 29 de noviembre · Demócrata

Improving attention to students is one of the objectives of the draft royal decree guaranteeing quality in private VET centers. To achieve this, the Ministry of Education, Vocational Training and Sports proposes reducing the number of students each teacher can attend and requiring a minimum teaching dedication in virtual and blended modalities equivalent to that in-person.

The Government believes there is a need to ensure sufficient teaching staff for students, tutoring and assessment. Industry sources, consulted by DEMÓCRATA, say they agree on this need. The disagreement arises over how to organize those resources and what obligations are necessary to improve training.

The ministry acknowledges that reducing ratios will increase teaching costs and argues that this effort will allow for more individualized monitoring and better learning outcomes. However, it does not quantify how much those results would improve with each reduction nor does it compare that option with other ways of strengthening support for students.

The draft from the Milagros Tolón department is being processed, and on 10 November the Council of Ministers requested an urgent opinion from the Council of State, with a deadline of 19 November.

What the draft requires of virtual VET teachers

The Education proposal combines two changes that affect the organization of staffing.

The first is a progressive reduction of the maximum number of students per teacher and professional module in the virtual offerings of degrees D and E: 80 at the start of the 2028-2029 academic year, 65 in 2029-2030 and 50 in 2030-2031. For the blended modality, the text examined sets a maximum of 25.

The professional module is the unit of reference: the limit is not calculated on all students enrolled in the center. In addition, the in-person activities of a virtual offering must respect the ratios of the corresponding in-person teaching.

The second change appears in Article 6.3. It establishes that the total number of teaching and tutoring hours assigned to virtual and blended teachers may not be less than that provided for the same degrees in-person, without prejudice to the specific conditions of each modality.

They are different requirements. One determines how many students a teacher can attend; the other sets a minimum number of teaching and tutoring hours using in-person teaching as the reference.

The Ministry calculates an 80% increase in the cost of teaching staff per student

Attending to fewer students per teacher will increase the cost of virtual VET. This is reflected in the Ministry’s report: in its calculation, moving from 90 to 50 students per professor increases teaching expenditure from 429 to 772 euros per student and course.

It is 343 euros more per student, approximately 80%. The explanation is simple: to maintain the same number of students with smaller groups, centers need to devote more teaching staff resources.

The calculation uses a reference remuneration of 25,750 euros per year and an allocation of 1.5 teachers per course. The 90 students are the starting point chosen for the estimate, not the accredited situation of all centers.

That 80% is not a forecast of an increase in tuition fees. It refers exclusively to the estimated teaching staff cost by the Ministry. How much it would be reflected in the price paid by the student will depend on other expenses and the decisions of each center.

Education expects better results, but does not measure how much they would improve

The Government’s justification is that a teacher with fewer students can dedicate more attention to each one, detect difficulties and follow their learning more closely. The report considers that the reinforcement will contribute to improving quality and does not foresee a significant reduction in the system’s capacity to meet demand.

It also notes that the implementation schedule will allow centers to plan their staffing over three academic years.

The question left open is why the final limit must be 50 students and what specific improvement is expected to be obtained with that number. The report presents a projection of benefits, but the economic analysis examined does not translate them into measurable objectives for reducing dropout, increasing attainment, or improving care.

There is also a limitation in the baseline data: the document acknowledges that it does not have consolidated and homogeneous information on ratios per virtual cycle in private centers. Therefore, the 90 students used as a reference do not represent a verified situation for all centers. The effort required to adapt will be different depending on how each one is working currently.

The industry’s objection: not all tasks need the same group size

Industry sources agree with the Ministry on the need to guarantee tutoring and follow-up. What they question is using a uniform figure for activities with different needs.

Explaining common content, correcting assignments, supervising practices, and addressing an individual difficulty do not necessarily require the same organization. Therefore, they propose allowing different groups and split classes depending on the activity, provided that the center can demonstrate that it offers sufficient support.

The criticism is not about defending that a teacher can take on any number of students. It calls for the limit to be justified by taking into account the methodology, the complexity of the module, the resources available, and the effective work of assessment and tutoring.

Why the matching of hours is also being called into question

The other objection from the sector to the ministry’s proposal refers to using the hours of in-person teaching as a minimum to organize the virtual format.

In a face-to-face class, a large part of the work is carried out with the teacher and the group assembled at a specific time. Virtual training combines live sessions with materials that the student consults at another time, independent activities, corrections, tutoring, and follow-up via the platform.

The observations argue that those differences must be reflected in the distribution of teaching work. They propose replacing automatic equivalence with sufficient and verifiable dedication, adapted to the number of students and the characteristics of each type of teaching.

This does not imply that digital resources replace teaching staff. Preparing content, updating it, correcting it, and supporting students also requires work. The debate is whether quality should be checked through an equivalence of hours with face-to-face teaching or through criteria that measure the support actually provided.

This obligation should also not be confused with the student’s connection hours: the article refers to the teaching staff’s dedication, not to the requirement that all virtual learning must be carried out live.

Who bears the cost and what happens with the places

The Ministry argues that reducing student-to-teacher ratios does not limit admissions: it requires strengthening resources to handle them. The sector warns of another possibility: that some centers pass on part of the increase in costs to enrollments or stop offering certain groups.

None of those effects on prices and places can be considered proven with the documentation available. But that the rule does not establish an overall global maximum for students also does not make it possible to ensure that all centers can maintain their offering after adapting to what the Government intends.

To assess that risk, enrollment data, staff levels, and costs per teaching are needed. It would also be necessary to analyze jointly the two teaching requirements: the additional teaching staff needed to meet a ratio may cover part of the new hours, so it would not be correct to add both costs without checking the possible overlaps.

The controversy thus centers on a specific question: what reinforcement each offering needs to improve care and how to finance it without hindering access.

The Government believes that fewer students per teacher and a minimally enhanced dedication will improve quality. The sector demands demonstrating why those parameters are the appropriate ones before turning them into general obligations. The remaining point is to link the expected economic effort with educational outcomes that can be verified.