The Fundación de Estudios de Economía Aplicada (Fedea), through a study by the professor at the Universidad Pompeu Fabra (UPF) Benito Arruñada, argues that "failures of policy worsen, rather than correct, those of the housing market" in Spain, by considering that "restrictions on building, transferring and contracting generate scarcity and especially harm those looking for housing".
The report, titled "The housing problem: scarcity and high cost by one’s own will", highlights that in the market for new housing, the lack of buildable land is due to "political decisions", since different groups and neighbors can stop a development without bearing the full cost of that decision.
Using data from the Comisión Nacional de los Mercados y la Competencia (CNMC), the study indicates that developing land can take between ten and fifteen years, "sometimes more than twenty", to which is added a tax pressure that, according to an assumption by the Consejo General de Economistas (CGE), represents 25.78% of the final payment made by the buyer.
Regarding used housing, the study notes that taxing transfers heavily and holding it relatively lightly "penalizes residential mobility" and contributes to numerous properties remaining vacant or being used below their potential.
In this context, it recalls that the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OCDE) advises Spain "to gradually reduce taxes on transfers", whose rates are among the highest of the member countries.
In the rental market, the document concludes that setting rent ceilings, imposing mandatory renewals and making recovery of housing more difficult protects the tenant already in place, but does so at the expense of those looking for an apartment, by pushing landlords to "withdraw supply and select more solvent tenants".
Regarding the 2020 Catalan regulation, the study includes estimates that point to a "mean rent reduction close to 5% and a drop in new contract signings near 10%".
It also warns that non-payment insurance reduces the individual risk for the landlord, but its selection criteria "exclude vulnerable candidates".
Assessment of the new housing decree
The study also analyzes the latest housing decree that was validated on November 12 by the Diputación Permanente del Congreso.
In addition to introducing new annual extensions of up to two years and caps on the updating of rents until the end of 2027, the regulation requires, in certain cases, the Administration to "offer a housing alternative or deal with the tenant's debt and legal costs" if two months pass without a solution.
For the author, this mechanism "partially captures the principle of financing assistance with public resources," although its effectiveness "depends on the payment being sufficient, timely, and enforceable".
Arruñada argues that these measures can be "electorally profitable" despite their social impact because "current beneficiaries identify the immediate advantage," while "future contracting parties perceive the cost of the opportunities they lose as worse".
In her view, this asymmetry is reinforced by moratoriums presented as exceptional and temporary, exceptions for small landlords, and taxes that are formally charged to banks or developers, which allows "to make the benefits visible and hide the harms".
Using microdata from surveys by the Centre d'Estudis d'Opinió (CEO), 40dB, and the Centro de Investigaciones Sociológicas (CIS), the study shows that support for the regulation depends on the respondent's contractual position.
In Catalonia, living in rented accommodation is associated with 12 percentage points more support for regulating prices than living in a home you already own and have paid off, while having another rented home is associated with 19.8 fewer points.
Likewise, in the CEO experiment, mentioning a bank or a fund as the owner of the home increases by 1.5 points out of ten the justification for occupying a property.
The author also warns that some surveys "present the intervention as a guarantee of access and omit its costs," so that disseminating its results as a "majority mandate" can consolidate support for tools whose negative effects have not been made explicit.
Five lines of reform to increase supply
To reverse the shortage and increase supply both of new-build and second-hand housing, the Fedea study proposes five main lines of reform.
First, it proposes making construction easier by expanding the uses and densities allowed, assessing the cost of the quality requirements, and reviewing which interests justify a veto and which can be protected through compensation.
It also advocates reorganizing taxation, reducing taxes on construction and transfers and avoiding taxing inflationary capital gains", as well as "offsetting the reductions with other income, including that from holding, or with lower spending".
It also calls for restoring legal certainty and freedom of contracting, respecting contracts, facilitating their enforcement and recovering the ability to agree on rents and terms, without discriminating against landlords based on their size.
Likewise, it asks to separate social assistance from private contracting, financing aid with explicit public resources and allowing the private sector to adapt, "avoiding placing the protection of the vulnerable on their landlord or creditor".
Lastly, it urges strengthening regulatory subsidiarity and transparency, so that differentiated solutions by territory are permitted, their results are compared and regulatory costs are made visible, in addition to "linking demographic polling percentages to the questions and alternative options that produced them".
As the author concludes, the main obstacle to these changes is of a political nature, since citizens demand "affordable homes without having to assume the consequences of allowing construction, transfer and contracting". "While we reward restrictions and hide their costs, we will continue to choose scarce and expensive housing," the report emphasizes.