The United Nations has expressed this Tuesday its "concern" regarding the agreement sealed between five member states of the European Union (Germany, Denmark, Greece, the Netherlands and Austria) and Rwanda to set up in 2027 a migrant deportation center on Rwandan territory. To these facilities, those who lack legal residence in those European countries may be sent, including those to whom the right to asylum has been denied, while the procedure is finalized for their definitive expulsion after rejecting the voluntary return to their country of origin.
"Although we do not know the text of the proposal, we are concerned about the risks to Human Rights that the transfer, set out in the proposal, of people from five EU countries to Rwanda entails," the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Volker Turk, has indicated. The official has underscored that the African country is a state with which these people "have no real link" and that, in addition, "it faces its own challenges in the area of Human Rights."
"We are aware of how complex, politicized and polarized the issues related to migration have become," Turk added, to then emphasize that "the solution does not lie in isolated measures, often extremely costly, that consist in looking for faraway countries to manage an aspect of migration governance, nor either in outsourcing the obligations related to Human Rights."
In this regard, he has said that the response to current challenges in the area of migration "lies in a deeper analysis of the factors that drive migration, which include various challenges in the area of Human Rights, deep inequalities in many parts of the world, an unfair economic and financial system that harms numerous countries of the Global South, an increase in violent conflicts and greater geopolitical tension."
"These problems must be addressed head-on and with determination, which implies making adequate investments that tackle the fundamental causes of migration and generate viable opportunities in countries of origin," he said, while also recalling that "at the same time, the societies of the Global North are rapidly aging and face both labor shortages in key sectors and challenges regarding the sustainability of their social protection systems".
For this reason, the High Commissioner has insisted that "all of this requires an integrated approach to migration governance, based on Human Rights, which includes the expansion of pathways for regular migration and recognizes the enormous contributions that migrants make to European societies and economies".
The pact with Rwanda constitutes the first agreement concluded by European Union countries with a third State to move out of the bloc part of migration management and of returns. This formula was not possible until the Twenty-seven agreed to a reform to toughen the policy of removals, a text against which Spain voted precisely because of the legal doubts raised by these deportation centers.