Fedea warns of the lack of financial sustainability of pensions despite the record employment and the reserve fund

Fedea questions the financial sustainability of pensions as the contributory deficit and debt surge despite the employment record and the savings fund.

fotonoticia 20261116092510 1920

fotonoticia 20261116092510 1920

Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Ask FREN

Published

5 minutes

Most read

Elecciones 29N · Encuestas

La media de las encuestas

Media a 16 de noviembre de 2026 · 16 institutos

  • PP31,4 %
  • PSOE27,0 %
  • Vox19,0 %
  • Frente Amplio6,2 %
  • ERC2,5 %
01020304050ene 2024jul 2024ene 2025jul 2025ene 2026jul 2026

Media del último estudio de cada instituto en 30 días y su evolución semanal desde el 23J. Partidos con al menos un 2 %.

Todas las encuestas

Elecciones generales del 29 de noviembre · Demócrata

ELECCIONES 29N

¿Cuál es tu pronóstico? 29N

Reparte los 350 escaños del Congreso como creas que quedarán el 29 de noviembre. Puedes cambiar tu pronóstico hasta que cierren los colegios.

0 de 350 escaños

PP
PSOE
Vox
Frente Amplio
ERC
Junts
EH Bildu
PNV
Más partidos
Podemos
BNG
SALF
CC
UPN
Adelante
Aliança
Otros

Protegido por reCAPTCHA de Google: privacidad y condiciones

Pronóstico de DemócrataParticipación abierta, no es una encuesta

The Foundation for Applied Economic Studies (Fedea) has pointed out this Monday that Spain's public pension system can continue paying its benefits as long as the State continues to assume its imbalance, but it rejects that it can be described as "financially sustainable". The reason is that the contributory deficit is already around 4% of GDP, has continued to increase even in a context of record employment, and will worsen with the massive retirement of people born in the 'baby boom'.

These conclusions are set out in a note from Fedea prepared by the researcher from the University of the Hespérides, Santiago Calvo, in which he analyzes the system's accounts and its role in the electoral debate.

The work confronts the arguments defended by the Government during the campaign for the general elections of 29 November with the figures from the Expanded Social Security (SSA) calculated by Ángel de la Fuente for Fedea, the reports of the Independent Authority for Fiscal Responsibility (AIReF), and the official data available.

According to Calvo, the references used by the Executive to support the strength of the system — the 2023 reform, the closure of the Reserve Fund this year at around 20,000 million euros, two AIReF endorsements to the spending rule, and a labor market with 22.4 million contributors and 2.51 contributors per pensioner — "are not false, but taken together they provide an incomplete picture of the system's financial situation".

"The figures revised in this note do not allow us to talk about a system on the verge of collapse, because a pay-as-you-go system backed by the State can continue paying its benefits as long as the State is willing to cover its deficit and the markets are willing to finance the debt that this generates," explains the researcher.

However, he adds that "they also do not allow us to claim that the system is financially sustainable in the sense that its defenders give to its current situation".

An "iceberg" of debt under the pension pot

The report recalls that the Reserve Fund, popularly known as 'the pension pot', reached in 2011 66,815 million euros in current terms (72,700 million euros in constant 2021 terms) and began to be emptied starting in 2012 to finance the payment of pensions, until it was reduced to something more than 2,000 million in 2019.

Since 2023 the Fund has been increasing again thanks to the Intergenerational Equity Mechanism (MEI), a surcharge on contributions that began at 0.6% and will rise to 1.2% in 2029, with which the “savings pot” had accumulated 15.267 billion by March 31, 2026.

At the same time, the Social Security’s debt to the State has surged from 18.500 billion euros in 2016 to 116.000 billion in 2025 (around 136.000 billion euros in current euros). “As the system continues to need loans to balance its accounts, what is being done in practice is to issue debt to finance an contribution to the Reserve Fund that does not respond to any surplus of the system,” the document warns.

Thus, the SSA’s net assets (Fund minus debt) have gone from exceeding 54.000 million euros in 2011 to being in negative territory, around 103.800 million in 2025. Calvo likens this situation to an “iceberg,” in which the “savings pot” represents only the visible part.

Below, he emphasizes, the debt with the State and the current transfers channeled since 2005 to fund Passive Classes, top-ups to the minimums, and other contributory items are concentrated, which add up to about 320.000 million euros. Taken together, the external resources received up to 2025 are around 436.000 million, compared with a “savings pot” of 12.200 million expected at the close of that year.

At the base of the “iceberg” are the pension rights already generated by workers in active employment and retirees, which Eurostat estimates at 5.58 trillion euros in 2021, the equivalent of 452% of GDP.

Contributory deficit of 3.8% of GDP in a context of record employment

With regard to the annual accounts, the analysis indicates that in 2025 the non-financial budgetary balance of the SSA recorded a deficit of 7.200 million euros from 2021 (0.5% of GDP), a result that is only possible because the State’s current transfers have risen from 0.5% of GDP in 2005 to 3.6% in 2025.

If those transfers are deducted, the basic deficit amounts to 59.400 million euros from 2021 (4.1% of GDP) and the contributory deficit stands at 54.300 million (3.8% of GDP). Between 2007 and 2025, contributory contributions have increased by 29% in real terms, while spending on contributory pensions has risen by 82%.

Fedea stresses that covering this gap through transfers "leaves intact the cost of the system for all the administrations and is limited to changing the place where the public accounts are recorded".

Demographics, pension spending, and AIReF warnings

On the demographic front, the text recalls that in 1975 there were 5.95 people aged 16 to 64 for every person over 64, a ratio that today stands at 3.15 and that, according to INE projections, will fall by 39% over the next 25 years, to 1.93 in 2050.

Spain faces this aging with pension spending of 13.2% of GDP in 2024, above the average of the European Union (12.6%), despite having an elderly dependency ratio three percentage points lower than the Community average (30.8% vs. 33.9%). If the average European relationship between both variables were applied, Spain would correspond to spending close to 10.1% of GDP.

The document cites actuarial studies that conclude that the system commits to paying, on average, 25% more than what is financed with contributions, while the AIReF expects gross pension spending to rise from 13% of GDP in 2025 to 16.4% in 2050.

Regarding the spending rule introduced in the latest reform, Calvo confirms that the AIReF endorsed its compliance by finding that net spending on revenue measures is at 13% of GDP, below the 13.3% threshold. However, it notes that the fiscal watchdog itself warns in its 2026 report that the references of this rule "bear no relation to the sustainability of public accounts, as shown by the fact that compliance with this rule is compatible with an increase in public debt in the coming years", which would reach 123% of GDP by 2050 while maintaining current policies, with implicit transfers to the pension system of 3% of GDP.

In addition, Fedea emphasizes that the pension rule allows spending to grow by 4% per year between 2025 and 2031, compared with the 3% cap agreed with Brussels in the Fiscal and Structural Plan for all primary net spending. This will, according to the report, require containing with greater intensity the advance of other public items—such as education, infrastructure, housing, or defense—or else resorting to more borrowing.

Proposals to strengthen the system’s viability

To face this scenario, the researcher from the Universidad de las Hespérides argues that protecting pensions implies ensuring that they can be paid without undermining the well-being of those who finance them. Along these lines, he proposes various measures, among them the implementation of notional accounts; the creation of a supplementary capitalization pillar, of a collective nature and with automatic enrollment, which would allow diversifying the sources of income for future retirees, and the periodic sending to each worker of an estimate of their future pension.

"None of these proposals involves privatizing the public pension system, and all of them seek to ensure that system continues to exist under reasonable conditions for those who contribute today," the author concludes.