Kallas now asks to leave behind the debate over who negotiates and focus on what is being negotiated with Russia

The High Representative assumes the decision of European leaders on the format of dialogue with Moscow and asserts the role of Community diplomacy in defining the terms of a possible peace, with a ceasefire in advance and without European concessions to the Kremlin as a starting point

79d0e272 0197 4871 845d 9e7d485a2e94

79d0e272 0197 4871 845d 9e7d485a2e94

Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Ask FREN

Published

4 minutes

Most read

Elecciones 29N · Encuestas

La media de las encuestas

Media a 16 de noviembre de 2026 · 16 institutos

  • PP31,4 %
  • PSOE27,0 %
  • Vox19,0 %
  • Frente Amplio6,2 %
  • ERC2,5 %
01020304050ene 2024jul 2024ene 2025jul 2025ene 2026jul 2026

Media del último estudio de cada instituto en 30 días y su evolución semanal desde el 23J. Partidos con al menos un 2 %.

Todas las encuestas

Elecciones generales del 29 de noviembre · Demócrata

ELECCIONES 29N

¿Cuál es tu pronóstico? 29N

Reparte los 350 escaños del Congreso como creas que quedarán el 29 de noviembre. Puedes cambiar tu pronóstico hasta que cierren los colegios.

0 de 350 escaños

PP
PSOE
Vox
Frente Amplio
ERC
Junts
EH Bildu
PNV
Más partidos
Podemos
BNG
SALF
CC
UPN
Adelante
Aliança
Otros

Protegido por reCAPTCHA de Google: privacidad y condiciones

Pronóstico de DemócrataParticipación abierta, no es una encuesta

After the leaders of the European Union agreed to entrust the dialogue on the peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine to a group of countries made up of Italy, Germany, France, Poland and the United Kingdom, in addition to the Community institutions, the EU high representative for Foreign Affairs, Kaja Kallas, calls for raising one’s gaze. Beyond the discussion about who should sit at the table, the head of European diplomacy is now proposing to delve into the "content rather than the 'conversation format'".

The fact is that the decision adopted by the heads of State and Government of Europe last Friday, during their summit in Dublin, dealt a setback to the former prime minister of Estonia. On arriving at the meeting, Kallas had asserted her role, in accordance with the treaties, as responsible for representing the interests of the Union in this kind of dialogue. However, the diplomatic sources consulted pointed to the fact that issues relating to the security policy of the member states ultimately fall to the capitals themselves.

"The leaders decided on the format, but we have to work on the substance, on the content. As we have done up to this point," Kallas said upon arriving at the meeting of foreign ministers held this Monday in Brussels. The high representative has argued that she maintains the necessary channels to continue contributing to the talks, regardless of the political configuration that the dialogue with Moscow will ultimately adopt.

In this regard, she recalled that she meets with the foreign ministers of the Twenty-Seven every month and that she has the experts of the European External Action Service (SEAE), who are familiar with the previous negotiations. "I can continue working on the substance to also keep the focus on the content," she said. A position with which Kallas tries to preserve the role of Community diplomacy in a process in which the member states have chosen to reserve greater political prominence for themselves.

Kallas rejects entering the security framework put forward by Moscow

Precisely regarding the terms of those negotiations, the head of European diplomacy considers that entering into a debate about the architecture of European security entails assuming Russia’s argumentative framework. Kallas has questioned the demands put forward by the Kremlin and has warned that discussing them in their own terms could grant legitimacy to claims that, in her view, have no basis.

"They are absurd demands that they have presented," she said. The High Representative wanted to recall that, in 2021, Russia already raised similar issues, which later served as a pretext to justify the start of the invasion of Ukraine. At that time, Moscow demanded a review of the principles that underpin European security, including guarantees regarding the expansion of NATO and the Western military presence on the continent. "We have a security architecture established and Russia has accepted it in many agreements. The problem is that Russia is not complying with those agreements," Kallas explained. In this way, the Community official placed Russia’s failure to meet international commitments at the center of the problem, as opposed to the possibility of reopening the debate about the rules that govern the security of the continent.

Brussels’ position therefore involves preventing the talks from ending up shifting the focus from Russia’s responsibility in the invasion toward a renegotiation of the principles of European security. A line that also conditions the Community approach to any possible concessions that may be put forward during the negotiating process.

A ceasefire before negotiating the terms of peace

The European Union continues to demand a ceasefire as a prerequisite to begin "really" discussions "about anything else." A possibility that, according to Kallas, is not currently apparent, especially in view of the intensification of Russian attacks on Ukrainian infrastructure. The High Representative has emphasized attacks on transportation infrastructure, such as trains and bridges, and has warned that Moscow maintains a strategy aimed at increasing pressure on the civilian population. Brussels believes that the Russian objective is "to cause the greatest possible suffering to civilians so that Ukrainians surrender before this harsh winter."

The absence of de-escalation signals on the ground contrasts with diplomatic efforts to guide a negotiated exit from the conflict. For EU diplomacy, it is difficult to address the conditions for lasting peace while Russia continues to intensify its military operations and to attack essential infrastructures for the functioning of the country.

Kallas has also harshly criticized the possibility that the European delegation might have to present an offer of concessions to Russia as a starting point for the talks. "It's the handbook they always use," she replied to journalists, before mocking the possibility that "all of a sudden it might be our turn to offer them something." The head of diplomacy insisted that it was Russia that started the war and, therefore, it is not appropriate to frame the process as a negotiation between two parties with identical responsibility for the origin of the conflict. "There is an aggressor and a victim," she recalled, before calling for any progress toward a just peace to include concessions on Moscow's part.

"We need to see concessions from their side so that we can have a just peace," she argued. Kallas's position thus points to one of the main disagreements hovering over diplomatic contacts: who should bear the political and territorial costs of a possible agreement and under what conditions it can be guaranteed that the ceasefire will not end by consolidating Russia's military advances. In recent days, it has emerged that the United States would have put forward a proposal that would contemplate Ukraine's entry into NATO in exchange for Kiev handing over to Russia part of the territory of the Donbas. A formula that illustrates the complexity of the talks and that puts back at the center of the negotiation the security guarantees and the possible territorial concessions.

Play

Test your knowledge with FREN!

How much do you know about this topic? Answer the following 3 questions.

What has Kaja Kallas requested regarding the approach to peace negotiations with Russia?

Question 1 of 3

What precondition does the EU require to start peace talks with Russia?

Question 2 of 3

Why does Kaja Kallas reject debating the European security architecture according to Moscow's demands?

Question 3 of 3