A U.S. federal judge has allowed to proceed a lawsuit filed by the tenant of the White House, Donald Trump, against the newspaper "The New York Times" and the publishing house Penguin Random House, following a book edited in 2024 by the latter and signed by two journalists from the aforementioned paper which, under the title "Perdedor afortunado" ("Lucky Loser"), describes the rise of the Republican magnate in the real estate business.
In his ruling, district federal judge Steven Merryday, appointed at the time by former President George H. W. Bush, has concluded that Trump could come to prove that the authors intentionally made false statements about him.
"Anyone who publishes the claim that another person has committed a complex nature of the kind of crime described in some of the challenged statements* necessarily acts with specific motives to doubt the veracity of their statements and with knowledge at a high degree of probability that they are false," he wrote in the ruling, reported by the news portal The Hill. "In other words, they know they don't know, but that doesn't deter them," he added.
The "Times" had tried to strike down Trump’s allegations by arguing that, while ordinary plaintiffs only have to prove the falsity of a statement, public figures must also show that the defendant acted knowing that what he was saying was false or with a "reckless disregard" for the truth.
Although the magistrate has now allowed the White House chief’s lawsuit to proceed, the newspaper itself has noted through its spokesperson, Charlie Stadtlander, that it continues to "believe that the remaining allegation in the lawsuit lacks any legal basis." "We look forward to presenting this argument as we continue to defend ourselves against this unfounded attack on 'The Times' and the rights of the free and independent press in this country," it said in a statement to The Hill.
This proceeding adds to Trump’s previous lawsuits against the "Times" and the "Wall Street Journal," both dismissed; to the cases in which he reached out-of-court settlements with CBS News and ABC News in 2024; and to the lawsuit still underway against the BBC, which he likewise accuses of defamation.