Manuela Carmena criticizes the way the Justice system works: "Who are we writing the rulings for?"

The former deputy mayor of Madrid questioned the usefulness of part of the judicial work during the presentation of the book by Álvaro Lobato.

fotonoticia 20261027104543 1920

fotonoticia 20261027104543 1920

Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Ask FREN

Published

Last updated

2 minutes

Most read

Elecciones 29N · Encuestas

La media de las encuestas

Media a 19 de noviembre de 2026 · 19 institutos

  • PP31,0 %
  • PSOE27,7 %
  • Vox19,0 %
  • Frente Amplio6,2 %
  • ERC2,6 %
01020304050ene 2024jul 2024ene 2025jul 2025ene 2026jul 2026

Media del último estudio de cada instituto en 30 días y su evolución semanal desde el 23J. Partidos con al menos un 2 %.

Todas las encuestas

Elecciones generales del 29 de noviembre · Demócrata

Manuela Carmena questioned the use of time and resources in the courts during the presentation of the book Justice, who is responsible? The world changes, justice does not, by the magistrate Álvaro Lobato Lavín. The former judge summarized her criticism with a sentence: "In justice, a lot is worked on in a very useless way."

The meeting, held on November 18 at Fide’s headquarters, also brought together the former Minister of Justice Rafael Catalá and the author of the work. The participants addressed the inertia of the judicial organization and the difficulties in assessing how it functions. The interventions pointed to different problems: from the day-to-day management of the courts to the criteria for appointing positions and the lack of incentives to improve the performance of judicial bodies.

The former mayor of Madrid cited as an example the record-ordering proceedings that are limited to acknowledging the filing of a submission. In her view, actions of that type consume time and resources without providing a substantial advance to the procedure. She also criticized the retention of forms of work that she described as "absurd mental utensils."

Carmena argued that the management of the courts must be approached as a function differentiated from the task of judging and proposed that that responsibility fall to specialists. At the end of her remarks, she left a question about the ultimate purpose of judicial decisions: "Who are we writing the rulings for?"

Catalá calls for objective criteria for appointments

Rafael Catalá focused his remarks on the system for appointing judicial positions. He considered that the lack of objective criteria makes it possible to negotiate quotas and defended more transparent procedures, based on the evaluation of capabilities and with participation from specialists in human resources.

The former minister also questioned the model of technological modernization. "We have incorporated a lot of technology, but to do the same thing," he said. Among the changes he proposed are reorganizing civil servant bodies, measuring workloads, and strengthening training in team leadership for those who aspire to government positions.

Lobato’s book puts the focus on judicial culture

Álvaro Lobato Lavín, a magistrate of the Commercial Courts in Barcelona, returned to the judicial career in 2022 after more than two decades of professional practice in the private sector. This dual experience serves as a starting point for analyzing the routines, incentives, and the institution’s capacity for transformation.

In Justice, who answers? The world changes, justice does not, the author argues that the main problem is not a lack of economic resources, but an organizational culture that barely measures results and offers little response to the lack of change. The work raises the need to evaluate how the courts function and assume responsibilities without turning that review into a threat to judicial independence.

More key points, information and questions with FREN

AI-GENERATED CONTENT

What steps are necessary to reform the system for appointing judicial positions in Spain?

To reform the system for appointing judicial positions in Spain, it is necessary to distinguish which appointments are intended to be changed and which rules are established in the Constitution. The conditions and procedures established by law can be modified through legislative reform; constitutional rules require first reforming the Constitution. Therefore, there is no single procedure applicable to all positions.

1. Define the scope of the reform

It is advisable to separate the election of the members of the General Council of the Judiciary (CGPJ), the governing body of judges, from the judicial appointments made by this Council, such as certain presidencies and magistracies of the Supreme Court. The magistrates of the Constitutional Court have their own regime: this court is not part of the Judiciary.

The proposal must specify whether it changes who elects, the requirements for candidates, the majorities, the evaluation criteria, or the guarantees of transparency and control.

2. Determine if an organic law is sufficient

Article 122 of the Constitution establishes that the CGPJ has twenty members, appointed by the King for five years: twelve among judges and magistrates and eight among lawyers and other jurists of recognized competence, with more than fifteen years of professional practice. Of the latter, four are proposed by the Congress and four by the Senate, by a three-fifths majority.

The selection procedure for the twelve judicial members can be reformed through the Organic Law of the Judiciary, respecting constitutional limits. The requirements and procedures for other appointments can also be legally modified: calls, publicity of candidacies, hearings, merit evaluation, motivation, and appeals.

However, changing the number of members, their term, the constitutional distribution of its members, or the three-fifths required for the eight jurists requires a constitutional reform. Modifications to the Constitutional Court must also be contrasted with its specific constitutional rules.

3. Process the legislative reform

The Government can present a bill, or the legitimized subjects can promote a proposal. If it comes from the Government, a preliminary draft is prepared and the mandatory reports are obtained; a reform on judicial organization and functioning requires attending to the CGPJ's report.

Then come the parliamentary presentation, amendments, committee and subcommittee work, and the vote. An organic law requires an absolute majority of the Congress in a final vote on the whole: at least 176 deputies.

The Senate can approve the text, introduce amendments, or veto it. The veto requires an absolute majority of the Senate; the Congress can override it by absolute majority immediately or by simple majority after two months. Amendments return to the Congress, preserving the organic approval requirements. Finally, the King sanctions and promulgates the law and it is published in the Official State Gazette (BOE); its application begins when the text provides.

4. Reform the Constitution when necessary

A modification of article 122 follows, in principle, the procedure of article 167: three-fifths of each Chamber and reconciliation mechanisms if they disagree. If the Senate reaches an absolute majority, the Congress can approve it by two-thirds. There is a referendum if requested, within fifteen days, by one-tenth of either Chamber.

The aggravated procedure of article 168 only applies if the reform affects its protected matters: it requires two-thirds of both Chambers, dissolution, new elections, ratification and approval by the new Cortes, and a mandatory referendum.

5. Provide for the transition

The reform must regulate current mandates and pending appointments, respecting judicial independence. A caretaker Government cannot present bills. With the Cortes dissolved, the reform cannot be completed: the Permanent Deputation does not replace their ordinary or constituent legislative power.

What are the specific functions of a former Minister of Justice and how do they differ from those of a magistrate?

In the Spanish legal system, the figure of a former Minister of Justice and that of a magistrate are radically different in nature, functions, and institutional position. They share having been linked to the Administration of Justice, but operate on very different levels: the former in the political–governmental sphere, the latter in the strictly jurisdictional sphere.

1. What a former Minister of Justice is and does

A Minister of Justice is a high-ranking official of the Executive Branch, a member of the Government, responsible for justice policy: directing the Ministry, proposing regulations, managing resources, relating institutionally with the Judiciary, etc. However, once they leave office, they become simply a former minister, an essentially political and honorary status, not a position with its own functions.

From a legal point of view:

  • There is no “position” of former minister with defined competencies in the laws. Leaving office extinguishes all executive functions.
  • What they retain, if applicable, are rights and obligations derived from having been a high-ranking official: subsequent limits for working in the private sector (revolving doors), duty of confidentiality regarding reserved information, registration of interests, possible right to pension/compensation according to applicable regulations, etc.
  • They may continue exercising political or public influence, but personally or as an officeholder in other positions (deputy, senator, lawyer, lecturer, member of boards, etc.), not by being a former minister per se.
  • The status of former minister has mainly protocolary and symbolic relevance: they may be cited as such in events, public debates, investigative commissions if summoned, etc., but those interventions depend on the new position they hold or specific invitations, not on a permanent competence.

In summary, the former Minister of Justice does not have their own legal functions merely by being “former”; their role becomes that of a citizen (or another position they may hold) with the singularity of their previous political experience and certain subsequent limitations/duties.

2. What a magistrate is and does

A magistrate is a career judge who exercises jurisdiction: part of the Judiciary. Unlike the former minister, their position is clearly defined by the Constitution and organic laws.

Their core functions are:

  • To judge and enforce what is judged: resolving conflicts by applying the law (criminal, civil, administrative, social, etc.) and ensuring their rulings are enforced.
  • Guarantee fundamental rights: effective judicial protection, right of defense, criminal guarantees, procedural rights, control of administrative actions, etc.
  • Act independently: they cannot receive orders from the Government, Parliament, or other authorities on how to resolve a specific case. Their only subjection is to the Constitution and the law.
  • Impartiality and neutrality: subject to strict incompatibility regimes (cannot hold political offices, cannot advise parties in litigation, etc.).
  • Professional responsibility: they may incur disciplinary, civil, or criminal liability if they breach their duties, but enjoy guarantees to protect their independence.

Additionally, the magistrate has a stable professional statute: access through competitive examination and judicial career, immovability except for specific causes, specific remuneration and incompatibility regime. Their role is technical and jurisdictional, not political.

3. Main differences between a former Minister of Justice and a magistrate
  • Nature of the role:
    • Former Minister of Justice: ex–high official of the Executive Branch. Political role, already ended.
    • Magistrate: active member of the Judiciary. Jurisdictional, technical, and independent role.
  • Source of their “functions”:
    • Former Minister: no longer has functions derived from the office. What they do afterward depends on new positions or private activities.
    • Magistrate: their functions come directly from the Constitution and laws regulating judicial organization.
  • Relationship with politics:
    • Former Minister: has been a top-level political actor; may continue intervening in politics through parties, media, or think tanks.
    • Magistrate: must remain apart from partisan struggle; their legitimacy rests on neutrality.
  • Type of decisions:
    • Former Minister (while in office): decisions of public policy, management of the justice system, drafting regulatory projects.
    • Magistrate: individualized decisions on specific cases, applying existing regulations.
  • Continuity over time:
    • Former Minister: their status depends on political cessation; inherently temporary.
    • Magistrate: long professional career, with stability and immovability.

In summary, a former Minister of Justice is basically a political figure who has ceased office, without their own public functions except those assumed in new positions or by invitation. In contrast, a magistrate is an organ of the Judiciary with permanent functions to judge, protect rights, and apply the law with independence and neutrality.

Could you explain in more detail exactly what the Minister of Justice did while in office? What professional limitations and incompatibilities does a magistrate have in Spain? What happens if the same person has been a magistrate and then Minister of Justice: what implications does this have when returning to the judicial career?

What legal requirements exist to modify the management of courts and who can promote them?

In Spain, modifying the management of courts does not always require an organic law: the instrument depends on what is intended to be changed. The structure of the Judiciary and the statute of judges have greater guarantees than the organization of offices, buildings, or resources. It is also necessary to distinguish between who can propose a reform and who has the competence to approve it.

1. What changes require a law

Article 122 of the Constitution reserves to the Organic Law of the Judiciary the "constitution, functioning, and governance of the Courts and Tribunals," as well as the statute of judges and magistrates and the personnel serving them. Therefore, changing the types of courts, the bases of their governance, or the essential elements of that statute requires reforming the LOPJ. This reservation is explained in Judgment 128/2018.

Approval of an organic reform requires an absolute majority of the Congress in a final vote on the whole, in addition to parliamentary processing and passage through the Senate. This special majority is not required for any administrative measure related to Justice.

The judicial plant —the existing bodies and positions— and the districting —the territory served by each body— are specified through ordinary state legislation, without prejudice to modifications that the law allows the Government to execute. Judgment 62/1990 distinguishes these decisions from the general definition of the judicial model, reserved for the LOPJ.

2. What can be changed through regulations

Development and organization measures can be approved through regulations or administrative decisions when they fit within the attributed competencies and respect the laws. A regulation cannot replace a legal reform nor alter by itself the essential guarantees of judges.

The organization of judicial offices and common services —teams that centralize support and processing tasks— allows intervention by the Ministry of Justice and the competent autonomous communities. Judgment 294/2006 explains this distribution and the need for coordination between administrations.

3. Who can promote and approve changes
  • Government: can present bills and approve development provisions corresponding to it. Manages judicial resources where that competence is not assumed by an autonomous community.
  • Congress and Senate: can promote bills and are those who process and approve legislative reforms. In Congress, they can be promoted by a parliamentary group or a deputy with fourteen other signatures.
  • Autonomous parliaments: can request the Government a bill or submit a proposal to Congress. Communities also participate in districting through legally provided mechanisms.
  • General Council of the Judiciary: can make proposals, indicate needs, and exercise its regulatory power within its attributions. It does not have direct legislative initiative nor replaces the Cortes.
4. Guarantees and limits

Government preliminary drafts on judicial organization must be submitted to the mandatory report of the CGPJ when appropriate: it is a mandatory procedure, not a general authorization. This requirement does not automatically apply to parliamentary proposals, according to Judgment 128/2023.

Autonomous communities can manage material resources and personnel within their competencies, but cannot assume governance of judges nor decide the content of rulings. In short, any reform must respect judicial independence, the distribution of competencies, and the required procedure; improving resources does not equate to modifying who judges or how they must decide.

Play

Test your knowledge with FREN!

How much do you know about this topic? Answer the following 3 questions.

What was Manuela Carmena's main criticism about the functioning of justice?

Question 1 of 3

What did Rafael Catalá propose regarding the judicial appointment system?

Question 2 of 3

According to Álvaro Lobato, what is the main problem of the judicial system?

Question 3 of 3