The story about a possible case of pneumonic plague in Siberia has generated a succession of versions that still do not fit together. What is confirmed is the death, on October 2, of a 28-year-old worker from the Irkutsk Anti-Plague Research Institute, after being hospitalized with severe pneumonia. What is not confirmed is that she suffered from plague.
The Russian health authorities maintain that the woman died from pneumonia of unknown origin and assure that no plague has been detected among the people who were in contact with her. Around 200 contacts were initially placed under observation or quarantine and, according to the information communicated by Russia, the tests conducted have not found dangerous pathogens.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has requested more information from Moscow. Its director general, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, explained on October 7 that the WHO had requested the results of the tests conducted on the deceased worker and her contacts, as well as information about the reasons that led to the adoption of public health measures. The organization is also trying to verify information about a second employee with pneumonia of unknown cause. The WHO states that it still does not have all the necessary information to conduct a complete risk assessment.
A death and a suspicion that Russia does not confirm
The origin of the alarm is in the workplace of the deceased. The woman worked at an institute specialized precisely in plague and other dangerous diseases. The first information disseminated about the case pointed to a possible accidental exposure to the bacteria that causes pneumonic plague, but that hypothesis has not been confirmed by the Russian health authorities.
Rospotrebnadzor, the Russian agency responsible for consumer protection and health surveillance, has assured that no cases of plague have been detected among the worker's contacts. The authorities also communicated to the WHO that no cases of plague had been reported in the Irkutsk region.
Featured story
The WHO awaits the official response from Russia regarding the possible pneumonic plague in Irkutsk.
2 minutes
The situation has led to thousands of tests being conducted among the people under surveillance. According to the information transmitted by the Russian authorities, nearly 5,000 tests have been conducted and no dangerous infections have been found among the contacts. The quarantine measure has been relaxed as cases among those people have been ruled out.
This does not equate to having explained what exactly the cause of the pneumonia suffered by the worker was. The question that remains open is precisely that: what caused the illness that ultimately led to her death.
Is there a second case?
The second source of uncertainty comes from reports about another person who would have developed pneumonia in the same area. The WHO has confirmed that it is trying to verify that information, but has not confirmed that it is a case of plague.
Russia has publicly rejected the reports about a second case of plague. The Kremlin has accused numerous media outlets of spreading false information and has referred to the information provided by Rospotrebnadzor.
What role does the United States play in the case
The international dimension of the story is partly explained by the uncertainty about the origin of the disease and by the characteristics of pneumonic plague, a severe form of the disease that can be transmitted between people through respiratory particles.
The United States has been following the case. Secretary of State Marco Rubio called on Russia to share more information and noted that Washington was closely monitoring the situation. President Donald Trump also stated that he did not consider the death to be related to a biological weapon and said that, according to Moscow, the situation was under control.
The WHO is in a similar position regarding the need for information: it has offered technical assistance on plague and biosafety, but acknowledges that it still does not have all the necessary data to make a complete assessment.
For now, the three issues that can be separated are clear: Russia claims that no plague has been detected among the contacts; the WHO believes it needs more information to clarify what happened; and reports about a second case remain unverified. The exact cause of the worker's death continues to be the main unknown.