The existence of residues of plant protection products (the medicines of plants) in agricultural products is one of the main concerns that European citizens point out in the successive Eurobarometers of the European Union. Therefore, despite the controls on Maximum Residue Limits (MRL) showing that they are not exceeded and that food is safe, for decades, community authorities have been reducing the active substances that combat pests, diseases, and weeds in the fields. A controversial measure since, in a global market like the agri-food sector, such prohibitions guarantee quality, but condition the competitiveness of the European farmer.
CropLife is the international organization that groups the main multinational plant protection companies and with which organizations like the Spanish Association for the Protection of Plants AEPLA are linked. Demócrata has spoken with the director of CropLife Europe, the Portuguese Olivier de Santos, about different aspects that are currently being negotiated in the Omnibus on Food Safety and Feed, such as allowing the use of drones for the application of plant protection products or the New Genomic Techniques that will allow improving crop productivity thanks to genetic editing.
QUESTION. For decades, Europe has been reducing the number of active substances that can be used to fight against crop diseases, so that, for example, in the United States they can use double what we can. What is the situation in the European Union?
ANSWER. It is a complex debate that cannot be reduced to a simple comparison between Europe and other regions. The reality is more complex. Our competitiveness depends on access to innovation and the speed with which a new solution reaches the market. And in the last six and a half years in Europe, 89 substances have been banned and only one new one has arrived. This is the difference between the active substances that are removed and the new ones that are authorized.
Q. And how does this situation affect the competitiveness of the European agricultural sector compared to other areas of the world?
R. European farmers are among the most productive and sustainable in the world, but they are increasingly working under more pressure. The famous Omnibus Food and Safety, the one on Food Safety and Feed, is an opportunity to improve the availability of plant protection products and expand new and effective tools for farmers. The ultimate goal is simple: an agile system that does not lower the food safety standards of European consumers, but is sustainable and competitive, which, in our opinion, is not contradictory, but goes hand in hand.
"The agriculture of the future will feature a combination of solutions: synthetic products, biologicals, precision agriculture, digital tools, or genetic improvement."
Homogeneity among member states
P. In recent years, biological control and biological treatments have been proliferating. Will they replace synthetic chemicals or will the latter always be necessary?
R. It is not a debate of choosing between one product or another. The agriculture of the future will feature a combination of solutions: synthetic products, biologicals, precision agriculture, digital tools, or genetic improvement. All of this makes up the toolbox for the field. Our goal is for farmers to have as broad a toolbox as possible, because agriculture needs more solutions and innovations, not fewer options.
P. Another issue is the lack of homogeneity of the substances allowed in the different states of the European Union. Although the European Commission greenlights certain products, there are countries that prohibit them, and there are cases of Spanish farmers traveling to other neighboring states to acquire them. How can we work on that homogeneity?
R. In the Omnibus debates, proposals are being studied to correct this fragmentation. The European Parliament has debated the idea of moving towards a single authorization zone for plant protection products, but the proposal is still under discussion. The Omnibus is an important opportunity to simplify and provide more options for farmers.
"The debate on simplification becomes complicated when it intersects with innovation, trade, and competitiveness."
P. What is the most complicated point in negotiating this regulation and what do you expect from the current Irish Presidency at the helm of the EU?
R. The debate on simplification becomes complicated when it intersects with innovation, trade, and competitiveness. There is broad consensus on simplifying the regulatory framework, but differences arise in how to do it and what unintended effects should be avoided. The particularly sensitive issues are the MRLs (Maximum Residue Limits) and data protection. The Omnibus will send a very clear signal of how Europe understands competitiveness, innovation, and the agriculture of the future.
Use of drones and NTGs
P. This Omnibus also addresses the use of drones for the application of phytosanitary products, a practice that is prohibited because Europe does not allow the use of planes to apply these products, but which is being done in the field, furtively. What do you think from CropLife?
R. Drones are an important tool for precision agriculture because they allow for more precise uses in difficult areas such as sloped terrain or wetlands, helping to better utilize resources,... The problem is that European regulation is slower than technology. The Omnibus proposes a specific pathway for certain applications with drones, but until it is developed, we need a transitional framework that provides security to farmers, operators, and national authorities. That framework should include three points: that member states can grant exemptions for this use of drones, have clear data to assess risks, and establish transitional measures that allow for safe and consistent use of drones in the application of phytosanitary products until the new European framework is fully operational.
"Communicating about agriculture requires translating technical and complex issues into matters such as food, price, sustainability, or food security."
P. Last June, the European Parliament approved the New Genomic Techniques (NTGs), which open a window to the use of genetic editing to obtain more resilient crops. What can this new tool mean for improving crop health?
R. The NTGs are an important tool in the toolbox for farmers. In June, a relevant political milestone was reached, but we have a lot of regulatory work to implement. The debate is shifting from political agreement to practical application; now it is time to talk about the details and how to make it something truly useful for farmers.
P. So, do they have quite a way to go?
R. More or less two years to have something more concrete.
Agricultural Communication and Society
P. Before leading CropLife Europe you worked at Burson, an international public relations, strategic communication, and reputation agency. What peculiarity does the field have when relating to society?
R. Few sectors are as visible and so poorly understood as agriculture. It is a sector that is at the crossroads of many issues: food, climate, health, trade, rural development. Therefore, public debate does not move solely based on data or science; values, perception, and emotion matter a lot. Communicating about agriculture requires translating technical and complex issues into matters such as food, price, sustainability, or food security. That is why it is so interesting and motivating to work for this sector.