Guindos sees political fragmentation as the biggest threat: “The true army of Europe today is the Ukrainian”

The former vice president of the ECB warns about the advance of populism and calls for regaining European relevance in a context of deteriorating transatlantic relations and competition with China

hb studios viernes21 fxfeu62

hb studios viernes21 fxfeu62

Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Ask FREN

Published

6 minutes

Most read

Elecciones 29N · Encuestas

La media de las encuestas

Media a 21 de noviembre de 2026 · 19 institutos

  • PP31,0 %
  • PSOE28,0 %
  • Vox18,9 %
  • Frente Amplio6,2 %
  • ERC2,6 %
01020304050ene 2024jul 2024ene 2025jul 2025ene 2026jul 2026

Media del último estudio de cada instituto en 30 días y su evolución semanal desde el 23J. Partidos con al menos un 2 %.

Todas las encuestas

Elecciones generales del 29 de noviembre · Demócrata

Internal political fragmentation, the deterioration of transatlantic relations, and China’s economic and technological competition, in the judgment of the former vice president of the European Central Bank (ECB) Luis de Guindos, constitute the main challenges facing the European Union. However, among them all, he singled out a risk above the rest: the difficulty for the Twenty-Seven in maintaining a common position in an increasingly demanding international scenario. “The true army of Europe today is the Ukrainian army. They are defending our values,” De Guindos said, who used his remarks to send a message to the new generations: “Let’s make Europe relevant again.”

The former vice president of the ECB took part this Friday in the opening of the V Forum on the Future of the EU, organized by Equipo Europa and the IE School of Politics, Economics & Global Affairs at the IE Tower in Madrid. Under the slogan European Security in a Changing World, the meeting brings together until Sunday nearly 800 young people and more than 85 speakers to debate the future of European security and the political, economic, and strategic challenges facing the continent. De Guindos showed little optimism about the short-term evolution of European politics and warned of the advance of populist forces. As an example, he pointed out that Alternative for Germany (AfD) is already positioned around 30% of voting intention. An evolution, in his view, makes it harder to build consensus and the Union’s capacity to respond to external threats.

The former vice president of the ECB also defended the need to address migration policy from a demographic and economic perspective. He considered that “orderly and legal” immigration is “absolutely indispensable” for Europe, at a time when population aging and the lack of generational replacement condition its growth outlook. “Europe always ends up choosing the correct alternative, but before it explores all the others,” he summarized, in a description of the difficulties of the community project to reach agreements and make decisions.

Jourová calls for changing the priorities of the European budget

The need to adapt the European Union's political and economic priorities to a context of greater international competition also focused the intervention of the former European Commission vice president Věra Jourová. Czech policy placed the defense of democracy and European values at the center of the Community project, although it warned of the distance it perceives between the institutions and part of the new generations. Jourová recalled her personal experience during the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968, when Russian tanks reached the streets of her city. From that perspective, she defined the European Union as "the guarantee that neither the Bolsheviks nor the fascists will return."

However, she warned that many young people have begun to see Europe as "a place for the old and the rich." For this reason, she called for concrete proposals to renew European democracy and asked the participants to contribute new ideas: "Turn on your fresh brains, because my generation isn't going to come up with it." On the economic front, Jourová put the focus on the future structure of the Community budget. The former vice president of the Commission defended reviewing the distribution of European resources to adapt them to the new strategic priorities, with greater emphasis on defense and technology.

In particular, she recalled that two thirds of the European budget have traditionally been earmarked for cohesion and agriculture, two policies that have underpinned Community spending for decades. Her proposal points to a review of that balance in light of the new needs for security and competitiveness. The enlargement of the Union was another of the issues discussed. Jourová described it as a "historical necessity," although she warned that the entry of new Member States requires, beforehand, a reform of European institutions to ensure that they function.

She also referred to commercial tensions with the United States over European digital regulation. In the face of Washington's tariff threats against Community rules, she defended that the EU's response should have involved the introduction of a digital tax.

González Laya claims an Europe based on shared sovereignty

The former Spanish minister of Foreign Affairs and current dean of the Paris School of International Affairs at Sciences Po, Arancha González Laya, addressed the debate from the political definition of the European project and her position regarding transformations in the international order. González Laya described the Union as "450 million citizens who, voluntarily and every day, share sovereignty" to build a common future through commitments between States. A definition that set against the "identity-based" vision of the West defended by U.S. vice president J. D. Vance.

On trade matters, she recalled that global trade grew last year above the global GDP and argued that the impact of U.S. tariffs has fallen primarily on U.S. consumers and businesses. As she explained, 90% of those costs would have been borne by Americans. Against trade barriers, she argued for deepening the European single market as one of the main tools for strengthening the Union’s economic position. Along those lines, she pointed out that each point of tariff could be offset through greater integration of the internal market.

The former minister also spoke to young people who express their dissatisfaction with how European institutions work. Her message was to take advantage of that mobilization to drive change from within: "Use rage to change the system, not to end the European Union".

Estonia warns of Europe’s military dependence on the United States

The former president of Estonia Toomas Hendrik Ilves shifted the debate to the terrain of strategic capabilities and technological autonomy. From the experience of a country that has been warning for years about threats coming from Russia, he recalled the massive cyberattacks suffered by Estonia in 2007 as one of the first warnings about the dimension of hybrid warfare.

Ilves placed a significant part of European weaknesses on the lack of economic and technological integration. In his view, the Union has not yet completed the single market, the union of capital markets, or the integration of its electricity grids, which limits its ability to compete with other powers.

In particular, he warned that Europe is “an order of magnitude” behind the United States in investment in artificial intelligence. A gap, in his view, that reflects the consequences of fragmentation in the European market and the lack of scale to develop strategic technologies. His warning was especially forceful when it comes to defense. Ilves said that two of the most critical military capabilities, intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance, and command and control systems, continue to depend exclusively on the United States. This situation leaves Europe exposed to a possible U.S. “off switch” at a time of uncertainty about transatlantic commitment.

"We make sure that the Europeans are in the room" The day began with a warning from the director of the Forum, Santiago Slullitel, about Europe’s difficulties in guaranteeing its own security. "If they ask me whether today we can guarantee our own security, I would say no," he said, although he argued that the future of the continent “depends on us” and claimed responsibility for the new generations to build it.

The president of Equipo Europa, Delia Dinca, closed the afternoon with a reflection on young people’s participation in decisions that will shape the Community’s future. "Last week, the future of European security was negotiated in a room where the European Union could not enter. This evening, nearly 800 young Europeans are sitting in this one. We make sure that the Europeans are in the room," she said.

The Forum will continue this Saturday with eight thematic rooms devoted to different areas of Europe’s future and will conclude on Sunday with the adoption of the conclusions prepared by the participants. Equipo Europa, a non-partisan youth organization founded in Spain in 2019, currently has more than 8,000 members and works to bring Community institutions closer to new generations. Through educational initiatives, meetings, and outreach activities, it seeks to foster active and informed participation by young people in debates about the European project.

More key points, information and questions with FREN

AI-GENERATED CONTENT

What is the status of the reform of the European Union's migration policy and what are the next steps for its approval?

The central reform of European migration policy, the Migration and Asylum Pact, is already approved. As of November 21, 2026, there is no pending final vote on the original package: the priority is to complete its implementation and develop complementary measures. It is therefore important to distinguish between the approval of the Pact and subsequent reforms on returns or cooperation with third countries.

What has been approved and since when?

The European Parliament approved the ten legislative texts of the Pact on April 10, 2024, and the EU Council completed its adoption on May 14, 2024. Its acts came into force in June 2024, with a two-year preparation period; June 12, 2026 marked the start of the application of the new framework. This is reflected by the European Parliament and the EU Council.

The package combines border controls, common asylum rules, and a solidarity system among States. Its main changes are:

  • Pre-control: identification, biometric data, and health, security, and vulnerability checks.
  • Common procedures: border processing for certain applications and connection with return when protection is denied.
  • Responsibility and solidarity: rules to determine which country examines each application and support through relocations, funding, or operational assistance.
  • Eurodac: expansion of the European biometric information system to manage applications and detect movements between States.
  • Reception and guarantees: common conditions, international protection, independent monitoring of fundamental rights, and mechanisms for crisis situations.

The Commission's explanation details these components and emphasizes that implementation requires continuing to adjust procedures after June 2026.

What are the next steps?

These are not new procedures to approve the original Pact, but tasks to make it work uniformly:

  • Complete national adaptation. States must finalize legal changes, designate authorities, train staff, and have adequate reception facilities and border procedures.
  • Consolidate operational systems. This includes Eurodac, information exchanges, and cooperation with European asylum, border, and IT management agencies.
  • Execute annual solidarity. For the first 2026 cycle, a reference of 21,000 relocations or other solidarity efforts, or 420 million euros in financial contributions, was set. Spain, Italy, Greece, and Cyprus were identified as countries under migratory pressure, according to the Council agreement.
  • Monitor results and guarantees. The Commission must continue evaluating implementation, supported by European agencies; Parliament maintains political and budgetary control.
What additional reforms should be distinguished?

The common return system is a complementary initiative, not a pending approval of the 2024 Pact. The Commission announced a political agreement in June 2026. Likewise, rules on safe countries of origin and the concept of safe third countries have evolved through additional legislation. A political agreement should not be confused with the formal adoption and publication of each rule.

In Spain, the Government approved asylum and immigration draft bills in August 2026 to adapt national legislation. That announcement does not equate to approved laws: the texts had to return to the Council of Ministers before being sent to Parliament, according to Demócrata. In conclusion, the immediate challenge is the execution of the European framework, not its initial approval.

What are the competencies and political careers of Luis de Guindos, Věra Jourová, and Arancha González Laya?

Luis de Guindos, Věra Jourová, and Arancha González Laya have international careers, but their specialties are different: economics and finance, democracy and rights, and diplomacy and trade, respectively. It is important to distinguish the competencies they exercised in their main public offices from their subsequent responsibilities: as of November 2026, Guindos is no longer Vice-President of the ECB and Jourová is no longer part of the European Commission.

Luis de Guindos: economic policy and financial stability

An economist and State trade technician, he developed his public career in the governments of José María Aznar and Mariano Rajoy. He was Director General of Economic Policy and Competition Defense between 1996 and 2000, Secretary General of that area between 2000 and 2002, and Secretary of State for Economy between 2002 and 2004. Simultaneously, he participated in European economic coordination bodies, according to his ECB biography.

He was Minister of Economy and Competitiveness between 2011 and 2016 and Minister of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness between 2016 and 2018. His responsibilities included economic policy, financial regulation, competitiveness, and international economic relations, with industry added in his second term. Among his main actions was managing the banking restructuring and the European recapitalization program for the financial sector.

As Vice-President of the ECB between June 2018 and May 2026, he participated in its monetary and executive decision-making bodies. These were collegiate responsibilities, not powers to individually decide interest rates. The European Council appointed Boris Vujčić to replace him from June 2026. Later, his incorporation to IESE as a distinguished collaborator from September was announced, without being a full-time professor, according to Demócrata.

Věra Jourová: justice, values, and transparency

A Czech jurist, she began in municipal and regional administration. She was responsible for regional development in Vysočina, Deputy Minister of Regional Development between 2003 and 2006, a deputy elected by ANO between 2013 and 2014, and Minister of Regional Development in 2014. Her initial specialization was regional policy and European funding.

In the Juncker Commission, she was Commissioner for Justice, Consumers and Gender Equality between 2014 and 2019. Her portfolio covered judicial cooperation, fundamental rights, consumer protection, equality, and data protection, including the implementation of the General Data Protection Regulation.

Between 2019 and November 2024, she was Vice-President for Values and Transparency: coordinating democracy, rule of law, media freedom, transparency and electoral integrity, and fighting disinformation. She participated in the Action Plan for European Democracy and the European Media Freedom Act. Her career is detailed on the European Commission. Later, she took on university responsibilities in Prague and, since May 2026, is part of the ECB Ethics Committee, according to her institutional profile.

Arancha González Laya: foreign policy and international trade

A jurist specialized in European Law, her career is mainly institutional and multilateral. She worked at the European Commission in trade and external relations; between 2005 and 2013 she was Chief of Staff to the WTO Director-General, Pascal Lamy, and his representative to the G20.

Between 2013 and 2020, she directed the International Trade Centre, a joint United Nations and WTO agency focused on trade and development. Afterwards, she was Minister of Foreign Affairs, European Union and Cooperation between January 2020 and July 2021, with responsibilities over diplomacy, European affairs, cooperation, and consular protection, according to the European Commission.

Since 2022, she has been Dean of the Paris School of International Affairs at Sciences Po. Her current activity focuses on academic leadership and international relations, not on directing Spanish foreign policy.

What institutional requirements must be met for the enlargement of the European Union with new Member States?

The enlargement of the European Union (EU) is mainly regulated by Article 49 of the Treaty on European Union (TEU) and is supported by the doctrine of the “Copenhagen criteria.” When talking about “institutional requirements” for the accession of new States, it is necessary to distinguish between the demands that the candidate State must meet and the institutional steps that must be followed within the EU itself to accept its entry.

1. Formal eligibility requirements
  • European State: only a “European State” can apply for accession (Art. 49 TEU). This implies being a subject of international law recognized as a State and being geographically or politically linked to Europe.
  • Respect for EU values: the State must respect and commit to promoting the values of Article 2 TEU: human dignity, freedom, democracy, equality, rule of law, and human rights, including minorities.
2. Copenhagen criteria: material requirements

Although not a treaty article, the European Council set in 1993 the so-called “Copenhagen criteria,” which have become an essential political condition for any enlargement:

  • Political criterion: stable institutions guaranteeing democracy, rule of law, human rights, and minority protection. In practice, this translates into:
    • Free and periodic elections.
    • Separation of powers and independent judicial control.
    • Effective guarantees against corruption and abuse of power.
  • Economic criterion: existence of a functioning market economy and capacity to cope with competitive pressure and market forces within the EU.
  • Acquis communautaire criterion: administrative and legal capacity to fully assume and implement the EU acquis:
    • Transposing all EU law (treaties, regulations, directives, case law, etc.) into its legal system.
    • Having administrations and institutions capable of enforcing it (judges, regulators, control authorities, etc.).

Additionally, the European Council added the so-called absorption capacity criterion: the EU itself must be capable of integrating the new member without jeopardizing its institutional functioning.

3. Institutional procedure within the EU

Accession is not only a technical evaluation; it requires a sequence of formal decisions by EU institutions and Member States:

  • Application for accession: the European State submits an application to the Council of the EU.
  • Role of the European Commission:
    • The Council requests an opinion from the Commission on the candidacy.
    • The Commission assesses the degree of compliance with the Copenhagen criteria and recommends (or not) opening negotiations.
  • Decision of the Council of the EU:
    • Member States, meeting in the Council, decide unanimously to open accession negotiations.
    • During negotiations, the Council sets negotiation frameworks, also unanimously, and supervises progress chapter by chapter (competition, environment, justice, agriculture, etc.).
  • Role of the European Parliament:
    • It must give its consent to the accession treaty by majority of its members.
    • Without that consent, accession cannot proceed.
  • Accession treaty:
    • Once negotiations are concluded, an accession treaty is drafted that amends the founding treaties to include the new State.
    • This treaty is signed by all Member States and the candidate State.
4. National ratification and entry into force

The accession treaty must be ratified by:

  • All current Member States, according to their constitutional procedures (national parliament, and in some cases referendum).
  • The candidate State itself, also according to its Constitution.

Only when all ratifications have been deposited does the treaty enter into force on the date it sets, and the State officially becomes an EU member, with full representation in the Council, European Parliament, Commission (one commissioner), and other institutions and bodies.

5. Internal institutional adjustments in the EU

Enlargement also requires adapting the functioning of EU institutions internally:

  • Redistribution of seats in the European Parliament within the maximum limit set by the treaties.
  • Reallocation of votes and weightings in the Council (when qualified majority voting rules apply).
  • Adjustment of the number of commissioners and, if applicable, treaty reforms if the existing institutional framework does not allow absorbing more members without blocking decision-making.

In summary, enlargement requires both strict compliance with democratic, legal, and economic criteria by the candidate State and a complex process of institutional decisions within the EU and national ratifications, all under the key rule of unanimity of Member States to accept a new partner.

Play

Test your knowledge with FREN!

How much do you know about this topic? Answer the following 3 questions.

What challenge does Luis de Guindos consider the main one for the European Union?

Question 1 of 3

Which part of the community budget does Věra Jourová propose to redirect towards defense and technology?

Question 2 of 3

What did former Estonian president Toomas Hendrik Ilves warn about European military capabilities?

Question 3 of 3