Internal political fragmentation, the deterioration of transatlantic relations, and China’s economic and technological competition, in the judgment of the former vice president of the European Central Bank (ECB) Luis de Guindos, constitute the main challenges facing the European Union. However, among them all, he singled out a risk above the rest: the difficulty for the Twenty-Seven in maintaining a common position in an increasingly demanding international scenario. “The true army of Europe today is the Ukrainian army. They are defending our values,” De Guindos said, who used his remarks to send a message to the new generations: “Let’s make Europe relevant again.”
The former vice president of the ECB took part this Friday in the opening of the V Forum on the Future of the EU, organized by Equipo Europa and the IE School of Politics, Economics & Global Affairs at the IE Tower in Madrid. Under the slogan European Security in a Changing World, the meeting brings together until Sunday nearly 800 young people and more than 85 speakers to debate the future of European security and the political, economic, and strategic challenges facing the continent. De Guindos showed little optimism about the short-term evolution of European politics and warned of the advance of populist forces. As an example, he pointed out that Alternative for Germany (AfD) is already positioned around 30% of voting intention. An evolution, in his view, makes it harder to build consensus and the Union’s capacity to respond to external threats.
The former vice president of the ECB also defended the need to address migration policy from a demographic and economic perspective. He considered that “orderly and legal” immigration is “absolutely indispensable” for Europe, at a time when population aging and the lack of generational replacement condition its growth outlook. “Europe always ends up choosing the correct alternative, but before it explores all the others,” he summarized, in a description of the difficulties of the community project to reach agreements and make decisions.
Jourová calls for changing the priorities of the European budget
The need to adapt the European Union's political and economic priorities to a context of greater international competition also focused the intervention of the former European Commission vice president Věra Jourová. Czech policy placed the defense of democracy and European values at the center of the Community project, although it warned of the distance it perceives between the institutions and part of the new generations. Jourová recalled her personal experience during the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968, when Russian tanks reached the streets of her city. From that perspective, she defined the European Union as "the guarantee that neither the Bolsheviks nor the fascists will return."
However, she warned that many young people have begun to see Europe as "a place for the old and the rich." For this reason, she called for concrete proposals to renew European democracy and asked the participants to contribute new ideas: "Turn on your fresh brains, because my generation isn't going to come up with it." On the economic front, Jourová put the focus on the future structure of the Community budget. The former vice president of the Commission defended reviewing the distribution of European resources to adapt them to the new strategic priorities, with greater emphasis on defense and technology.
In particular, she recalled that two thirds of the European budget have traditionally been earmarked for cohesion and agriculture, two policies that have underpinned Community spending for decades. Her proposal points to a review of that balance in light of the new needs for security and competitiveness. The enlargement of the Union was another of the issues discussed. Jourová described it as a "historical necessity," although she warned that the entry of new Member States requires, beforehand, a reform of European institutions to ensure that they function.
She also referred to commercial tensions with the United States over European digital regulation. In the face of Washington's tariff threats against Community rules, she defended that the EU's response should have involved the introduction of a digital tax.
González Laya claims an Europe based on shared sovereignty
The former Spanish minister of Foreign Affairs and current dean of the Paris School of International Affairs at Sciences Po, Arancha González Laya, addressed the debate from the political definition of the European project and her position regarding transformations in the international order. González Laya described the Union as "450 million citizens who, voluntarily and every day, share sovereignty" to build a common future through commitments between States. A definition that set against the "identity-based" vision of the West defended by U.S. vice president J. D. Vance.
On trade matters, she recalled that global trade grew last year above the global GDP and argued that the impact of U.S. tariffs has fallen primarily on U.S. consumers and businesses. As she explained, 90% of those costs would have been borne by Americans. Against trade barriers, she argued for deepening the European single market as one of the main tools for strengthening the Union’s economic position. Along those lines, she pointed out that each point of tariff could be offset through greater integration of the internal market.
The former minister also spoke to young people who express their dissatisfaction with how European institutions work. Her message was to take advantage of that mobilization to drive change from within: "Use rage to change the system, not to end the European Union".
Estonia warns of Europe’s military dependence on the United States
The former president of Estonia Toomas Hendrik Ilves shifted the debate to the terrain of strategic capabilities and technological autonomy. From the experience of a country that has been warning for years about threats coming from Russia, he recalled the massive cyberattacks suffered by Estonia in 2007 as one of the first warnings about the dimension of hybrid warfare.
Ilves placed a significant part of European weaknesses on the lack of economic and technological integration. In his view, the Union has not yet completed the single market, the union of capital markets, or the integration of its electricity grids, which limits its ability to compete with other powers.
In particular, he warned that Europe is “an order of magnitude” behind the United States in investment in artificial intelligence. A gap, in his view, that reflects the consequences of fragmentation in the European market and the lack of scale to develop strategic technologies. His warning was especially forceful when it comes to defense. Ilves said that two of the most critical military capabilities, intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance, and command and control systems, continue to depend exclusively on the United States. This situation leaves Europe exposed to a possible U.S. “off switch” at a time of uncertainty about transatlantic commitment.
"We make sure that the Europeans are in the room" The day began with a warning from the director of the Forum, Santiago Slullitel, about Europe’s difficulties in guaranteeing its own security. "If they ask me whether today we can guarantee our own security, I would say no," he said, although he argued that the future of the continent “depends on us” and claimed responsibility for the new generations to build it.
The president of Equipo Europa, Delia Dinca, closed the afternoon with a reflection on young people’s participation in decisions that will shape the Community’s future. "Last week, the future of European security was negotiated in a room where the European Union could not enter. This evening, nearly 800 young Europeans are sitting in this one. We make sure that the Europeans are in the room," she said.
The Forum will continue this Saturday with eight thematic rooms devoted to different areas of Europe’s future and will conclude on Sunday with the adoption of the conclusions prepared by the participants. Equipo Europa, a non-partisan youth organization founded in Spain in 2019, currently has more than 8,000 members and works to bring Community institutions closer to new generations. Through educational initiatives, meetings, and outreach activities, it seeks to foster active and informed participation by young people in debates about the European project.