Members of the European Parliament already have on their desks the draft of the future Cloud and Artificial Intelligence Development Act (Cloud and AI Development Act, CADA). The rapporteurs have presented their proposed report, thereby opening the phase in which the different political groups will try to incorporate their positions into an initiative that aims to consolidate the continent’s technological sovereignty and reduce its dependencies on third countries.
The text sets out four different levels of assurance at EU scale to regulate security, operational autonomy, and the location of data in computing services. In this scenario, the Socialist group intends that the rule that comes out of its processing in the European Parliament, before negotiations begin with the member states, guarantees a “people”-centered approach. This is a position that the Spanish government has been defending in the different legislative debates on the digital sphere that are currently taking place in Brussels.
“Each law is an opportunity,” the Socialist MEP and member of the Committee on Industry, Research and Energy (ITRE), Nicolás González Casares, said this week during a closed-door meeting. The parliamentarian argued that the continent “needs rules to also recover citizens’ trust” in technological development that works “not only for the digital world, but also for people.” One of the aspects he considers fundamental in the future legislation is precisely the regulation of the minimum performance standards of the infrastructures.
Four levels of assurance and common criteria for the Twenty-Seven
What the EU Executive is pursuing with this initiative is to harmonize the efforts of the member states and establish a common framework that will make it possible to guarantee the development of a sector considered strategically important for the Union. Regulatory fragmentation and differences in national criteria can hinder both the expansion of infrastructures and Europe’s capacity to compete in a market increasingly shaped by computing and the development of artificial intelligence model.
"If you cross Germany, Finland, Denmark or Portugal you will find different approaches," explained González Casares. Hence the MEP argues for the need to establish common requirements at the European scale, although with room to adapt them to the characteristics of each territory. In his view, the objective should be to prevent harmonization from turning into regulation alien to the material conditions in which infrastructures operate.
Featured story
MEPs study giving priority to European companies in public contracts for AI
7 minutes
"You have to take geographical realities into account. Not all Member States have the same energy mix or the same climate," he added. A particularly relevant consideration for legislation that will have to address the impact of data centers on electricity consumption, the availability of water resources, and the needs of national networks.
The issue takes on a particular dimension at a time when the expansion of artificial intelligence is multiplying the capacity needs for computing. Data centers have become an essential infrastructure to support this transformation, but their growth also raises questions about access to energy, the sustainability of the facilities, and their integration into European power systems.
A sustainability label that does not reflect all of the consumption
González Casares is critical of some of the approaches being developed by the Community Executive, especially regarding the assessment scheme for these infrastructures. The socialist believes that the proposed classification system does not provide sufficient information to know the real impact of data centers.
"It is not enough," he argues. In his view, the mechanism works like a sustainability label that makes it possible to evaluate facilities based on certain indicators related to energy, water and resource consumption. However, the system does not allow knowing in a complete way the total volume of resources each data center needs to operate.
The parliamentarian regrets that the assessment includes no specific data on absolute electricity consumption, expressed in megawatt-hours or kilowatt-hours, as well as the total volume of water used and the amount of renewable energy consumed over the course of the year. He considers that these indicators would make it possible to have a more accurate picture of the environmental impact of the facilities, beyond the classification they obtain across the different efficiency parameters.
Featured story
Von der Leyen asks for million-euro investments for AI in the next European budget
5 minutes
"We have a very nice label, but we do not know the reality," he states. One of its main demands is that the future legislation allows a "clear" image to be obtained of what is happening with total emissions and the consumption of these infrastructures.
"When labels are added without knowing the total energy consumption of these data centers, we probably do not have a complete picture," he pointed out. The concern of the socialist therefore lies in the difference between measuring the relative efficiency of a facility and knowing the absolute impact that its operation generates. A relevant distinction in a scenario of accelerated growth in computing capacity, in which an improvement in efficiency indicators does not necessarily mean a reduction in overall consumption if the number or size of the facilities increases.
The growth of data centers, shaped by climate targets
Energy sustainability also occupies a prominent place in the draft report proposal presented by the rapporteur. The draft links the expansion of data center capacity to its compatibility with the European climate targets for 2050 and proposes that these infrastructures must actively contribute to the decarbonisation of the Community energy system.
Among the measures proposed is that, before declaring a particular area as an acceleration area for data centers, Member States must carry out an impact assessment. The exercise would have to verify that the projected electricity demand for the new installations is compatible with the objectives set out in their respective Integrated National Energy and Climate Plans (PNIEC), as well as with households’ supply needs.
It is a matter of introducing a planning criterion that allows anticipating the consequences of the concentration of these infrastructures in certain territories. Authorization of new areas would not depend solely on the availability of land or on the ability to attract investments, but also on the possibility of guaranteeing electricity supply without compromising other uses or the climate commitments undertaken by the Member States.
The draft adds that these areas must endeavor to cover practically 100% of their energy demand through local, zero-emission renewable sources. When it is not technically feasible to achieve that supply directly and continuously, the rest of the needs may be met through grid electricity, storage systems, or flexible demand management mechanisms.
The proposal thus seeks to reconcile the rollout of new computing capacity with the energy transition, preventing the expansion of digital infrastructure from translating into additional pressure on national power systems. In this sense, the availability of clean energy becomes one of the elements that will condition the establishment and growth of data centers.
Interconnecting facilities to reduce pressure on the grid
Another of the aspects addressed by the document is the possibility of taking advantage of the combined capacity of smaller data centers or those distributed geographically. The draft analyzes the feasibility of interconnecting these facilities so that they can train artificial intelligence models in parallel, rather than concentrating all computing capacity in large infrastructures.
This approach would make it possible to leverage resources already available and to connect facilities more quickly, while also opening the door to more flexible management of workload. Among its possible advantages is the reduction of electricity consumption during periods of peak demand on the grid, through distributing computing tasks across different facilities. The issue connects with one of the major challenges that future legislation will have to address: how to increase Europe’s computing capacity without shifting all the energy and environmental costs of that growth to the territories where the infrastructures are concentrated.
With the draft already on the table, political groups now begin to shape their priorities and the modifications they intend to introduce in the report. The socialists see in this phase an opportunity to strengthen demands for transparency, sustainability, and control of consumption, in legislation that not only aims to promote European digital infrastructure, but also to determine under what conditions it must be developed.