Costs, access and legal certainty, the objections of the sector that advise reviewing the Royal Decree on Vocational Training (FP) before approving it

The Government has requested an urgent report from the Council of State on the quality project for private VET centers. Sources from the sector are asking to review the implementation costs of the proposal, the new requirements it sets out, and the adaptation deadlines before approving it.

EuropaPress 7894165 ministra educacion formacion profesional deportes milagros tolon atiende

EuropaPress 7894165 ministra educacion formacion profesional deportes milagros tolon atiende

Add DEMÓCRATA to Google

Ask FREN

Published

6 minutes

Most read

Elecciones 29N · Encuestas

La media de las encuestas

Media a 21 de noviembre de 2026 · 19 institutos

  • PP30,9 %
  • PSOE28,0 %
  • Vox19,0 %
  • Frente Amplio6,3 %
  • ERC2,6 %
01020304050ene 2024jul 2024ene 2025jul 2025ene 2026jul 2026

Media del último estudio de cada instituto en 30 días y su evolución semanal desde el 23J. Partidos con al menos un 2 %.

Todas las encuestas

Elecciones generales del 29 de noviembre · Demócrata

The project of the quality assurance royal decree for private vocational training centers moves toward approval with several open questions: how much it will cost to apply the new obligations, how they will affect the provision, and what conditions will be for students who are already enrolled.

On November 10, the Council of Ministers requested from the Council of State a urgent opinion. The Ministry of Education, Vocational Training and Sports, headed by Milagros Tolón, seeks to ensure that centers have sufficient teaching staff, facilities and resources. To do so, it proposes new conditions regarding the minimum range of programs offered, the number of students per teacher, and the in-person attendance of virtual training, among other measures.

Sources from the private training sector agree on the need to strengthen the quality of vocational training, but question whether all these requirements are sufficiently justified. They ask to assess their combined effects and review those that could hinder the activity of centers or students’ access without providing a demonstrable educational improvement.

How much will it cost to apply all the changes

One of the main sector criticisms is that the obligations will be applied at the same time and to the same centers, so these will have to adapt staff rosters, timetables, facilities and training offerings, as well as comply with new requirements for monitoring and documentation.

The ministerial report estimates part of that effort. In the scenario used for virtual vocational training, moving from 90 to 50 students per teacher, as Education proposes, would increase the teaching cost from 429 to 772 euros per student and course: approximately 80% more.

The figure refers to estimated teacher spending by the Ministry. It does not mean that enrollments will rise by 80% or that it includes the entire cost of delivering a program.

Sector sources call for expanding the calculation to include the needs for space, the organization of in-person activities, and the expenses that students may have to assume for transport or childcare. They also ask to study what happens when all the measures are combined.

The Ministry considers that strengthening teaching staff will improve individualized attention and does not foresee a significant reduction in the system’s capacity to meet demand. Sector sources warn, on the other hand, that some centers could shift costs to enrollments or reduce certain programs.

These are risks that must be evaluated.

Why the minimum offer is being questioned

The ministerial project requires private centers to provide an in-person offer of D degrees —the vocational training cycles— that meets one of two conditions: two professional families with at least two cycles in each, or a basic, intermediate, and advanced degree pathway from the same family when that structure exists.

It also includes the obligation to offer basic degree when the authorized families have qualifications at that level.

The Government wants to ensure a stable offer with sufficient resources. Sources in the sector, however, question that forcing the teaching of more courses demonstrates the quality of what a center already offers. Their argument is that a specialized center may have good teachers, appropriate equipment, and accredited results without needing cycles from other areas. Expanding its catalog would mean hiring staff, having facilities, and making investments for courses that may not have sufficient demand. For this reason, they ask that authorization focus on checking the means and the quality of each offer, without making the size of the center a general condition for continuing its activity.

In-person requirements and teaching staff with stricter rules

sector objections to the project also affect virtual and blended vocational training. The project introduces a general minimum of in-person teaching activity in virtual education, progressively reduces ratios, and links teachers’ teaching and tutoring hours to those of the in-person modality.

Sources in the sector maintain that these requirements must be adjusted to each course. Not all competencies require the same amount of practice, the same equipment, or the same teaching organization.

They propose that physical attendance be determined by the learning that requires it and that teachers’ dedication be adapted to tasks such as tutoring, marking and corrections, preparation of materials, and individual follow-up.

The concern is that overly uniform regulation removes flexibility from those who study at a distance because they work, have family responsibilities, or live far from a center.

Quality and differences between centers

Another point of discussion is the treatment that centers receive depending on who owns them or how they are funded. Title I sets conditions for private centers and excludes those that are supported with public funds.

Sources from the sector call for justifying that difference. They argue that if a requirement is essential to guarantee the quality of the same education, its application must meet equivalent criteria, regardless of the center’s regime.

They also request clarification of the situation of centers that combine publicly funded, grant-aided teachings with others financed through private tuition. They demand avoiding that this coexistence forces them to reorganize offers that already have authorization.

The question raised is what control or operating differences justify different obligations and which ones should be common.

Why the Government processes it by urgency

The ministerial report defends accelerating the rule, through its urgent processing, so that centers and administrations have, as soon as possible, the necessary framework to plan the changes. The Government also invokes the implementation timelines for the VET system and the need to avoid uncertainty about the offering, admissions, academic organization, and accreditations. It adds that administrations need time to adapt procedures and platforms.

Sources from the sector, for their part, consider that explanation insufficient. In statements to DEMÓCRATA, they indicate that the growth of private and virtual VET is a known process and they ask to specify what circumstance forces shortening the ordinary deadlines. "Urgent processing is absolutely unjustified. The reasons they cite in the report are directly false. Royal Decree 659 has been in force for a long time and, based on it, the Autonomous Communities have regulated without any problem or need for this new text. This could be a cause for challenging the rule, just as has happened with the universities’ RD", they warn.

They also demand, time to debate the articles and their consequences with business and union organizations. In their view, participation should make it possible to study alternatives and introduce changes before approval.

What will happen to current centers and students

The project provides for up to the 31st of December 2030 so that centers that are already authorized adapt to the conditions of Title I. The reduction in ratios has its own calendar, which culminates at the start of the 2030-2031 academic year.

Sources from the sector ask for a clear explanation of which deadline corresponds to each obligation, especially to the changes to modalities, in-person delivery, and teaching organization introduced through the final provisions.

They propose to extend the adaptation until the start of 2032-2033 and to apply the changes in full academic courses. That date is a request from the sector, not an approved deadline.

They also demand an express guarantee for those who are already studying: that they can complete their studies under academic conditions equivalent to those they had when they enrolled and that any reorganization preserves their training, assessment, and degree-awarding.

The revisions the sector is calling for

The sector’s response to the proposal from the ministry includes adjusting in-person attendance to the competencies of each degree, allowing a teaching organization adapted to virtual teaching, and avoiding procedures that repeat checks already carried out by another administration.

They also ask for the controls to distinguish between documentary errors and serious quality problems, with possibilities for rectification before an authorization is withdrawn when there is no risk that requires acting immediately.

With the advisory opinion from the Council of State requested, the project will enter a relevant phase of its processing. The Government defends new guarantees for students. Sources from the sector call for that, before approving them, it be clarified how much each one costs, what improvement each one provides, and how it will be ensured that they do not hinder access to FP.