The European Commission is finalizing the details of its proposal to limit minors' access to social networks. The President of the Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, received this Monday the advisory report she commissioned from an independent panel of experts, a document that, as she has advanced, will serve as the basis for future "actions" on a European scale aimed at strengthening the protection of children and adolescents in the digital environment.
"We must consider gradual and phased access for different age groups," the German leader stated during the report's presentation, hinting that Brussels is leaning towards a staggered model in which the possibilities of access and use of digital platforms increase progressively as the minor gets older.
The European Executive will now analyze the recommendations of the group of experts, made public this Monday, with the aim of presenting a legislative proposal after the summer. The timeline coincides with one of the year's major political milestones: the State of the Union debate, scheduled for September, where the Commission usually announces its main legislative initiatives.
Featured story
Goodbye to lying about age on the internet: Europe activates its definitive solution
5 minutes
Von der Leyen considers the political context to be particularly favorable for addressing this debate. "There is already a consensus on the need to establish a minimum age for children to join social networks," the president assured, reflecting a growing concern among both Member States and European institutions themselves about the impact these platforms have on the mental health and development of minors.
Platforms will have to demonstrate that their services are safe
One of the main changes in philosophy proposed by Brussels consists of shifting responsibility from families to large technology platforms. The Commission wants companies to prove that their services are safe for minors, not the other way around. "In Europe, whoever develops a product is responsible for its safety," Von der Leyen argued, using a very graphic comparison. "We don't expect children to design their own seatbelts, nor do parents have to install airbags at home," she stated.
With this analogy, the president wanted to make it clear that the objective is to apply the same principle of protection to the digital environment that already exists in other areas of consumption.
Brussels' position comes just a few days after the Commission communicated its preliminary conclusions against Instagram and Facebook, considering that the design of both platforms could breach the Digital Services Act (DSA) by incorporating potentially addictive mechanisms, such as infinite scroll or automatic content playback. For the Community Executive, these investigations reinforce a fundamental idea: platforms have a legal duty to ensure the well-being of their users, especially when they are minors.
A European application to verify age without sharing personal data
One of the pillars of the future European strategy will be the creation of a common age verification system, valid for the twenty-seven Member States. The Commission has been working for months on an application that allows users to prove their age without needing to reveal their identity or share personal information with the platforms. "The question is no longer whether children run risks online, but what we can do to give them a safer start on the web," argued Von der Leyen.
For her part, the Executive Vice-President for Technological Sovereignty, Henna Virkkunen, explained that the European solution will be based on the so-called zero-knowledge proof, a cryptographic technology that allows demonstrating that a person meets a certain requirement—in this case, age—without revealing any other data. "When users want to access a service with age restrictions, they will maintain full control of their data," assured the Community Executive's technology chief.
In practice, Brussels intends to prevent each Member State from developing its own verification system, which could generate regulatory fragmentation, higher costs for companies, and differences in the protection of minors within the digital single market. The objective is to create a single European mechanism, interoperable and recognized throughout the Union.
Self-declaration no longer convinces Brussels
Currently, most social networks establish a minimum age of 13 years in their terms of use to open an account. However, in practice, it is enough to enter a false date of birth to overcome this requirement. The Commission considers that this system of self-declaration has significant security deficiencies and is clearly insufficient to guarantee the protection of minors.
Community services emphasize that this model does not prevent children under 13 from accessing platforms, nor does it allow for adequate verification of whether a user is under 17, an aspect they consider necessary to correctly adapt the digital experience to each stage of development.
Furthermore, Brussels warns that some platforms, such as Snapchat, do not offer sufficiently effective mechanisms to report profiles belonging to minors, thus increasing the risk of exposure to harmful content or potentially dangerous situations.
Despite the political momentum the debate has gained, the Commission avoids promising immediate solutions. "We must set the age from which they can legally access social networks. This will not be infallible," acknowledge community sources. Von der Leyen herself has argued that the transformation will require time, just as it happened with other major public safety measures. "It took years to ban driving under the influence of alcohol or to generalize the use of seat belts. Big changes do not happen overnight," she stated. Beyond regulation, Brussels insists that the protection of minors will also require a cultural change among families and technology companies themselves.
No screens before the age of three
One of the most forceful recommendations supported by the President of the Commission consists of completely avoiding the use of screens before the age of three. "Children should only be exposed to social networks under the supervision of their parents, caregivers, or teachers and for a limited time," Von der Leyen has repeated.
The leader has also called on families to reclaim spaces away from the digital world. "Children need time to play, to make face-to-face friends, to make mistakes and learn from their mistakes. They need time to develop their own identity and their own personality before an algorithm shapes it. I think we should give them that time," she concluded this Monday.
The European debate coincides with a legislative offensive promoted by the Spanish Government. In an interview with Demócrata, on the sidelines of a European Union Youth Council of Ministers, the Secretary of State for Youth and Childhood, Rubén Pérez, already announced that Spain is considering raising the minimum age for a minor to create social media accounts to 16 years. "Currently, in Spain, the age required for a minor to transfer their data to a private operator is already 14 years. What we are doing now is raising that limit to 16 years. No minor could open a WhatsApp, Facebook, or any other platform account because, by accepting their terms of use, they are transferring their personal data," he explained then.
The expert report received by the Commission proposes a progressive introduction to the digital environment, organized into three main stages:
From 0 to 2 years: no social media use
-
Complete absence of exposure to social media and similar platforms is recommended.
-
Control must rest entirely with parents or caregivers.
From 3 to 13 years: supervised access only
-
Use would only be possible under active supervision by parents, teachers, or guardians.
-
The general restriction for minors under 13 years of age throughout the European Union remains, except for educational exceptions or with parental consent.
From 13 to 18 years: progressive autonomy
-
The minor gradually gains greater independence in the use of platforms.
-
The role of adults evolves from direct supervision to accompaniment and digital education.
-
Member States may introduce additional restrictions based on their national legislation.
The Government also wants to toughen the Penal Code
In parallel, the Spanish Government has opened a new legislative front through two transactional amendments to the Bill for the Protection of Minors in Digital Environments. The initiative aims to prohibit access to social networks for minors under 16 years of age, except in cases where platforms prove to the National Commission of Markets and Competition (CNMC) that they offer a sufficiently safe environment or when there is a strictly educational purpose.
However, the Executive wants to go even further. The amendments include a profound reform of the Penal Code to criminalize certain algorithmic practices when they contribute to amplifying illicit content, such as incitement to suicide, child pornography, or any other material especially harmful to minors.
Likewise, the Government proposes to introduce direct criminal liability for the executives of large technology platforms when they fail to comply with judicial orders to remove dangerous content. The measure even contemplates prison sentences for those corporate executives who deliberately ignore court rulings.
With this, both Brussels and Madrid are beginning to converge on the same idea: the effective protection of minors in the digital environment cannot rest solely on families, but requires much greater responsibility from large technology platforms, which are called upon to assume an active role in risk prevention and in the creation of truly safe digital spaces for children and adolescents.