The mail-in voting sets the agenda for the elections on November 29. The doubts initially raised by the president of the Community of Madrid, Isabel Díaz Ayuso, and the leader of Vox, Santiago Abascal, persist this Thursday while the PSOE has closed ranks with a system they label as "guaranteeing."
The controversy also leaves nuances within the Popular Party itself. Its spokesperson in Congress, Ester Muñoz, has stated that she understands that some citizens may have doubts about mail-in voting due to the "maneuvers" she attributes to Sánchez, while the national spokesperson of the party, Borja Sémper, has affirmed that he trusts "fully" both in the Spanish electoral system and in this voting modality.
To the discussion about mail-in voting, another distinct but related issue has been added regarding the guarantees of the electoral process: the composition of the electoral roll and the situation of Spaniards who acquired nationality under the grandchild law. The PP has approached the Central Electoral Board (JEC) to express its opinion on this matter, while Vox has also presented initiatives before the JEC and the Supreme Court.
Ester Muñoz "understands" the doubts and the PP approaches the JEC
The spokesperson for the Popular Group in Congress, Ester Muñoz, stated this Tuesday "understand" the suspicions that may exist about mail-in voting, although she has called on citizens to participate in the elections and has avoided explicitly asking that this modality not be used.
"I think it's normal. Seeing how Pedro Sánchez behaves [...] there may be people who have doubts," Muñoz has stated, linking those reservations to the "maneuvers" she attributes to the president of the Government.
The Popular leader has assured that she usually votes in person in León, but has left the choice in the hands of each voter. "Let people go vote and let no one stay at home", she has demanded.
At the same time, Muñoz has confirmed that the PP has submitted a document to the Central Electoral Board to express its opinion on the electoral roll that will be used on November 29.
"We have appealed to the Central Electoral Board," the parliamentary spokesperson explained, focusing her party's objections on the application of the so-called 'grandchild law' and on the assumptions used to grant Spanish nationality.
Sémper claims that the system is "clean and guaranteeing"
In the face of those suspicions, the national spokesperson of the PP, Borja Sémper, has expressly defended his confidence in the Spanish electoral system and in voting by mail.
"I fully trust the system and I believe that the system has guarantees and mechanisms to defend it", Sémper has pointed out. The popular leader has insisted that confidence must be maintained in the Central Electoral Board, which, he has argued, "is going to do its job" and will continue to guarantee that "the Spanish system is clean and is protective".
Sémper has also tried to downplay the scope of Ayuso's words and has rejected that within the PP there is any questioning of the functioning of the electoral system. In his view, the statements of the Madrid president should be interpreted as an understanding of the doubts that some citizens may harbor and not as a questioning of electoral guarantees.
In this way, the PP shares doubts about certain aspects of the census, but its leaders have shown different positions when it comes to conveying that distrust towards voting by mail.
Vox maintains its suspicions and calls for in-person voting
Vox has gone further in its accusations. Its parliamentary spokesperson, Pepa Millán, reiterated this Tuesday the suspicions of her party regarding possible irregularities related to voting by mail and defended that their reservations are based on "previous experiences".
"It is evident that we have all possible reservations, but we are not guided by inventiveness when we talk about voting by mail, we are guided by experience", assured the leader, who mentioned investigations into vote buying by mail in previous electoral processes.
Vox has thus again called on citizens to prioritize in-person voting on November 29, a recommendation that the party had already conveyed after the electoral call was announced. The party has also publicly insisted this Tuesday on precautions regarding voting by mail.
Rodríguez de Millán has also linked her suspicions to the composition of the census and to the nationalizations derived from the so-called 'grandchildren's law', which Vox believes may have electoral consequences. These are statements from the party that do not equate to the confirmation of fraud in the process of November 29.
The grandchildren's law brings the census battle to the JEC and the Supreme Court
The controversy over mail-in voting coincides with a different legal dispute over who should be part of the electoral roll, especially in the Electoral Roll of Absent Residents (CERA).
The PP has now requested a ruling from the Central Electoral Board, while Vox had already demanded that this body take into account the precautionary suspension agreed by the Supreme Court regarding certain registrations linked to the so-called 'grandchildren's law'.
The issue has become particularly relevant after the call for elections because the roll that must be used for the 29N was closed before the Supreme Court's precautionary resolution. The High Court also has pending the resolution of the appeal filed by the State Attorney's Office against that measure.
Sánchez responds that the system is "guaranteeing"
For his part, the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, has defended the guarantees of the Spanish electoral system and has recalled that mail-in voting has been used during numerous electoral processes.
The head of the Executive has defined Spain as a "guaranteeing system" and has emphasized that voting by mail is a right exercised for years.
Sánchez has also politically responded to the suspicions expressed by Ayuso and Abascal. In his opinion, it is significant that the doubts arise precisely among leaders who claim to face the elections with expectations of victory.
"Maybe they don't see it as obvious", Sánchez stated, suggesting that the questioning responds to their opponents not being sure of the election results.
The president had already rejected months ago Abascal's accusations of possible electoral rigging, reproaching him for launching such a serious accusation without providing evidence and defending then that Spain has a "transparent and clean" voting system.
Ayuso, at the origin of the controversy
The controversy had escalated on Monday when Isabel Díaz Ayuso asked citizens not to use mail-in voting and expressed her suspicions about possible "adulterations", also linking her doubts to the evolution of the roll.
KEYS OF VOTE BY MAIL
- How to request it. The voter can request the vote by mail from the electoral call and up to the tenth day before the voting. They can do it in person at Correos, proving their identity, or electronically through the systems enabled by Correos.
- Who controls the census. Correos does not decide who can vote nor prepares the census. The request goes to the Electoral Census Office, which checks that the citizen is registered and issues the corresponding certificate.
- You cannot vote twice. When the request is accepted, it is noted in the census that this voter has requested to vote by mail, which prevents them from subsequently voting in person at their polling station. The LOREG also establishes that no one can vote more than once in the same elections.
- The documentation is delivered identifying the voter. The Electoral Census Office sends by certified mail the ballots, envelopes, and the census certificate. The receipt must be personally signed by the voter upon proving their identity; if they are not at home, they must collect the documentation according to the legally established procedure.
- The vote travels certified and is recorded. Once the ballot is chosen, the voter places the vote and the census certificate in the envelope addressed to their polling station. Correos registers the received electoral documentation and that record is available to the Electoral Boards.
- Is it a guaranteeing system? The legislation incorporates identity controls, census certification, traceability of the shipment, custody, and supervision of the Electoral Boards and polling stations. In fact, the reform of the LOREG of 1992 expressly strengthened the procedure to increase guarantees regarding the identity and secrecy of the vote and incorporated criminal consequences for the willful violation of its procedures.